Surajmal Rambux v Laxminaryan Raghunath (1951)
High Court of Nagpur·1 January 1951
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
What are the different ways a granted patent can be revoked, and how does revocation differ from invalidity?
Revocation ends a patent before term and is void ab initio; besides a petition or counter-claim under section 64, a patent may be revoked consequent on an opposition under section 25(4) or a surrender under section 63.
Doctrine last updated on 14 November 2026
Revocation in Context, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/revocation
1The topic of revocation may be approached from the following three inter-related perspectives:
(1) Proceedings which lead to revocation of a patent; (2) Persons entitled to seek the revocation of a patent; and (3) Authorities who can revoke a patent.
2The Patents Act provides for various mechanisms by which a granted patent may be revoked. Other than the most common proceeding of revocation detailed in s 64, a patent may be revoked consequent to an opposition proceeding a post-grant opposition under s 25(4) of the Patents Act or a surrender proceeding (a voluntary surrender of a patent by the patentee under s 63 of the Patents Act).
3An opposition proceeding can also be regarded as a revocation proceeding since one of the possible results of an opposition proceeding is revocation of the patent. But the treatment of both the proceedings have been different in the Patents Act and the same will be followed here, though both the proceedings can be maintained on certain common grounds and can result in revocation. The most important distinction is that opposition proceedings are time-bound procedures which have to be preferred within a time period stipulated under the Patents Act, where as revocation proceedings may be instituted at any time after the grant of the patent, while the patent is in force. (Pre-grant opposition proceeding can be initiated anytime before the grant of patent, but as per r 55(1A) it must be done within six months after the publication of the application; post-grant opposition proceeding has to be initiated within one year from the date of publication of grant.) The decision of the Controller in an opposition proceeding will not act as res judicata in revocation proceeding before the high court. The right to oppose under s 25 and the right to revoke under s 64 exist independent of each other under the Patents Act. The grounds of opposition are not coterminous with the grounds of revocation. (That proposition comes from Surajmal Rambux v Laxminaryan Raghunath (1951) AIR 1951 Nag 284, a case decided under the Patents and Designs Act 1911 which compared the opposition proceedings under s 9 with the revocation proceedings under s 26, and concluded that an unsuccessful opponent could bring an action for revocation, on account of the difference in grounds, and the different stages in which they were preferred.) A person who unsuccessfully opposes a patent under s 25 shall be entitled to file a petition for revocation under s 64.
4Revocation and invalidity, though employed in similar context, have different meanings. (Patents Act 1970, ss 33(1), 33(2), 34, 56(1), 58(1), 103(2), 105(3) and 106(2).) As a patent has to be valid to be in force, the validity of a patent can be questioned at any time during the term of patent. (Ibid, ss 19(1)(a) and 19(2)(c). See also s 13(4), which states that the examination and investigations required under ss 12 and 13 shall not be deemed in any way to warrant the validity of any patent.) In fact, the Patents Act provides for instances in which a patent will not be regarded as invalid, and allows for the validity of the patent to be put in issue without petitioning for its revocation. (Ibid, s 11(8).) The Patents Act also provides for proceedings in which the validity of a patent shall not be called into question. (Ibid, s 103(2)(b).) But there will not be any difficulty to revoke a patent that is invalid (ie, expired). (Ibid, s 105(4).) When the validity of a patent (or a claim in the specification of a patent) is questioned it may lead to two consequences, ie, the patent may be revoked or the patent may be amended. (Star Textile Engineering Works v James Mackie Holdings (1977) (1978) IPLR 160, p 163. See also North Eastern Marine Engineering Company v Leeds Forge Company [1906] 2 Ch 498, p 500, (1906) 23 RPC 529, p 533.) Thus invalidity of a patent can lead to its revocation or to an amendment. (Patents Act 1970, s 58(1), which states that “in any proceedings for revocation the High Court decides that the patent is invalid, it may allow the specification to be amended under this section instead of revoking the patent.) The invalidity of a patent can be a cause for its revocation, but need not always result in revocation. (Ibid, s 113(1), where the High Court in a revocation proceeding under s 64 or s 104 comes to the conclusion that the validity of any claim that is contested before it is found to be valid, it may issue a certificate of validity stating that the validity of that claim was contested in the proceeding before it and was upheld.
5A patent may be revoked even after its expiry. In Star Textile Engineering Works v James Mackie Holdings (1977) (paras 13 and 18), the Court revoked the patent holding that “an action can be brought for infringement of a patent even after the term has expired and also an application for revocation is not barred even after the patent in question has expired.”
When can the Controller revoke a patent as a consequence of other proceedings?
What is the procedure for surrender of a patent under section 63?
Can the Central Government revoke a patent in the public interest without going to court?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/revocation