Surajmal Rambux v Laxminaryan Raghunath (1951)
High Court of Nagpur·Hidayatullah J·Single Judge·Decided 1 January 1951·AIR 1951 Nag 284
A person whose opposition failed may still apply to the High Court to revoke the patent on grounds outside those of opposition: the revocation application held competent.
Surajmal Rambux v Laxminaryan Raghunath, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/surajmal
Summary
“This is an Application under Section 26 sub-section (1), Patents and Designs Act, 1911, for the revocation of the patent. One of the grounds of objection to the Petition is that the Applicants had opposed the grant of patent under Section 9 of the Act, and that until the Applications have exhausted their remedy under Section 9 sub-section (3) of Appeal to the Central Government the present Application is not competent.” (para 1) Justice Bose had ordered “that before taking action under Section 28 sub-section (1), to which parties by common consent were agreeable, this point should be decided.” (para 2) “In the present case the Applicants had filed an Application opposing the grant of the patent.” “I understand that the Application was rejected as it was filed after the expiry of 4 months from the date of the advertisement.” (para 9)
The Court held that “The matters mentioned in Section 9 of the Act are not coterminous with those on which the High Court exercises jurisdiction under Section 26 sub-section (1).” (para 4) It found that “Section 26 deals with the revocation of a patent, while Section 9 deals with opposition to the grant of a patent. These are different stages” (para 7), and that the finality of the Central Government’s order “would manifestly be limited to those grounds which alone can be urged under Section 9 sub-section (1).” (para 8) “I hold, therefore, that the Application is competent. A date shall now be fixed for action on the Application.” (para 10)
What the court decided
- Opposition and revocation grounds. “The matters mentioned in Section 9 of the Act are not coterminous with those on which the High Court exercises jurisdiction under Section 26 sub-section (1). Under the former Section, the grounds on which the grant of a patent can be opposed are five in number. It is clearly stated in the Section itself that opposition can be on those five grounds and no other.” “I am concerned only with the competency of the Application, and, to my opinion, the Application as a whole and also in its several parts falls outside the scope of Section 9 of the Act.” (para 4)
- Who may apply for revocation. “An Application under Section 26 sub-section (1) can be made either by the Advocate-General or by any person who alleges one of the three matters mentioned in Section 26 sub-section (2) clause (b).” “The provisions of Section 26 sub-section (2) clause (b) do not lay down the grounds on which revocation can be sought. These are mentioned in clauses (a) to (n) of the earlier sub-section.” (para 5)
- Grounds open to the applicant. “A person who is competent under Sub-section 2 clause (b) is not restricted to the three allegations which determine his competency to make the Application, and can allege any of the grounds mentioned in subsection (1) of the Section.” (para 5)
- The grounds relied on. “The Applicants in the present case have relied upon Section 26 sub-section (1) clauses (b), (d), (e) and (i) of. These are not included in the grounds on which the grant of a patent can be opposed under Section 9 of the act.” Of “Section 9 sub- section (1) clause (d)”, the Court held: “That Clause deals with the public use or publication of the invention by the patentee or at his instance. This is clear from Sections 38 and 40 of the Act .” (para 6)
- An unsuccessful opponent. “Further, Section 26 deals with the revocation of a patent, while Section 9 deals with opposition to the grant of a patent. These are different stages, and at least in so far as the grounds are different and in the absence of any prohibition, it cannot be said that a person who has unsuccessfully opposed the grant of a patent cannot file an Application for its revocation.” (para 7)
- Finality of the Central Government’s order. “It is true that under Section 70 sub-section (3) of the Act the Order of the Central Government is final, but that would manifestly be limited to those grounds which alone can be urged under Section 9 sub-section (1). The finality would not attach to anything beyond those grounds” (para 8)
- Opposition rejected as out of time. “The Applicants admitted that they had not Appealed against that Order within three months, as they were required to do under Section 70 sub-section (1).” “examining the present Applications I find that the present grounds do not fall within Section 9 sub-section (1).” (para 9)
- Disposition. “I hold, therefore, that the Application is competent. A date shall now be fixed for action on the Application.” (para 10)
Subsequent treatment
Followed in SERGI Transformers Explosion Prevention Technologies v CTR Manufacturing Industries (2011), where the Bombay High Court reproduced para 7 (para 16) and held that the “Nagpur High Court in the case of Surajmal Rambux & Ors. (supra) has held that in the absence of prohibition, it cannot be said that the person who has unsuccessfully opposed the grant of patent, cannot file an application for its revocation. Similar view has been taken by Delhi High Court in the case of Dr.Aloys Wobben (supra).” (para 18)
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Revocation in Context
Case page · Page updated 27 October 2026
www.aop.onl/surajmal