Revocation Consequent on Other Proceedings
When can the Controller revoke a patent as a consequence of other proceedings?
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
What is the procedure for surrender of a patent under section 63?
Under section 63 a patentee may surrender his patent by giving notice to the Controller, and any person interested may oppose the surrender within three months of publication.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
Surrender of a Patent, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/surrender
1The Patents Act allows a patentee to surrender his patent by giving notice to the Controller. When the patentee makes an offer to surrender the patent, the Controller shall publish the offer and notify every person whose name appears in the register as having an interest in the patent. (Patents Act 1970, s 63(2).)
2Any person interested may file an opposition to the surrender of a patent within three months from the date of publication of notice by giving notice of opposition to the Controller in Form 14. (Patents Rules 2003, r 87(2).) The Controller shall inform the patentee of such notice on receipt of the same. The procedure for filing of written statement, reply statement, leaving evidence, hearing and costs shall be the same as that of an opposition to the grant of a patent detailed under rr 57 to 63. (Ibid, r 87(3).) On hearing both the parties, if the Controller is satisfied that the patent may be surrendered, he may accept the offer and pass an order revoking the patent. If the Controller accepts the offer to surrender the patent, he may direct the patentee to return the patent. Upon the receipt of such patent, the Controller shall by order revoke the patent and publish the revocation. (Patents Rules 2003, r 87(4).) The patent will cease to have effect from the date of publication of the Controller’s acceptance of the offer to surrender the patent. An appeal from an order revoking the patent consequent to the surrender will lie to the High Court. (Patents Act 1970, s 117A(2).)
3An application to surrender shall not be employed to revoke a patent application for an invention which was the subject matter of an earlier patent, as the same can be revoked on a separate ground under s 64 of the Patents Act. (See International Business Machines Corpn (Barclay & Bigar’s) Application (1983) RPC 283, p 287.) It will be open for the patentee to surrender its patent during the pendency of revocation proceedings, as the very object of providing for a patentee-initiated revocation in the form of an offer to surrender is to enable the patentee to avoid, if he so desires, revocation proceedings and its consequent costs. When an offer to surrender is made during the pendency of revocation proceedings, it is unlikely that the Controller will accept the same, as surrender proceedings and revocation proceedings have different consequences. A patent revoked pursuant to a revocation proceeding will be void ab initio. But a patent surrendered will take effect only from the date of acceptance of the offer of surrender by the Controller. In such proceedings, the Controller shall look into the conduct of the patentee and the grounds of revocation before accepting the patentee’s offer to surrender the patent. (See Connaught Laboratories Inc’s Patent [1999] FSR 284, p 288.) The Controller may also stay the application to surrender before him pending the outcome of a revocation. (See Dyson Ltd’s Patent (2003) RPC 24.)
When can the Controller revoke a patent as a consequence of other proceedings?
What are the different ways a granted patent can be revoked, and how does revocation differ from invalidity?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/surrender