Case page

Star Textile Engineering Works Ltd v James Mackie Holdings Ltd (1977)

High Court of Calcutta·Salil K. Roy Chowdhury J·Single Judge·Decided 6 June 1977·PTC (Suppl)(1) 226 (Cal)

Good law A petition under Section 64 revoking three patents (Nos. 87007, 87008 and 87009) for insufficient and unclear specifications; revocation was ordered though the patents had expired or were about to expire. No later treatment traced as of 9 November 2026.

A patent may be revoked where the complete specification does not sufficiently describe the invention or enable a skilled person to work it — even after expiry.

Cite this page

Star Textile Engineering Works Ltd v James Mackie Holdings Ltd, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/star-textile

Judgment PDF

Summary

“This is an application for revocation of a patent under Section 64(1) of the Patent Act, 1970” (para 1), relating to “three patents being patents Nos. 87007, 87008 and 87009 in respect of improvements relating to flyers for spinning and twisting machines” (para 3). The petitioners, “manufacturers of machinery for textile and jute industry” (para 4), sought revocation; the patentees and the Controller did not defend, the Controller stating that “he is not interested in the matter” and would “abide by” the Court’s order (para 2).

The Court held that the “complete specifications of the said patent do not sufficiently and clearly describe the respective inventions and method by which it is to be performed” (para 8), that “the specification does not disclose the best method of performing it which was known to the applicant” (para 9), and that the “claims of each of the complete specifications is not sufficiently and clearly defined” (para 10). It found “the ground for revoking the said patents under Section 64(1)(h), (i), (j)” established (para 12), and, holding that “an application for revocation is not barred even after the patent in question has expired” (para 13), passed “an order in terms of prayers (a) and (b)” revoking the patents (para 18).

What the court decided

  1. Insufficient description and enablement. The Court held that the “complete specifications of the said patent do not sufficiently and clearly describe the respective inventions and method by which it is to be performed” and that “the said specifications by themselves are not sufficient to enable a person in India possessing average skill in and average knowledge of the art to which the respective invention relates to work that invention.” (para 8)

  2. Best method not disclosed. The Court held that “the specification does not disclose the best method of performing it which was known to the applicant” “for the patent and for which the said applicant was entitled to protection.” (para 9)

  3. Claims not fairly based. The Court held that “the respective claims of each of the complete specifications is not sufficiently and clearly defined or that the respective claims of each of the respective complete specifications are not based on the matter disclosed in the respective complete specifications.” (para 10)

  4. Ambiguity in the specification. The Court held that in “patent No. 87009 numeral 12 has an ambiguous meaning and therefore the ground under Section 64(1) and (j) has been established.” (para 11)

  5. Grounds under Section 64 established. The Court held that “the petitioners have proved their case and established the ground for revoking the said patents under Section 64(1)(h), (i), (j) of the Patent Act, 1970.” (para 12)

  6. Revocation after expiry. The Court recorded that “an action can be brought for infringement of a patent even after the term has expired and also an application for revocation is not barred even after the patent in question has expired.” (para 13)

  7. Non-appearance as admission. The Court held, citing Taylor’s Patent, that where “the patentee in an application for revocation of the patent does not appear it amounts to an admission that the allegations in the applications are correct”, the patentee and the licensee here having “not chosen to appear”. (para 14)

  8. Patents revoked. The Court held “There will be an order in terms of prayers (a) and (b)” and, the applicant having “not pressed for costs”, made “no order as to costs.” (para 18)

Subsequent treatment

No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 9 November 2026.

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cited in

Case page · Page updated 9 November 2026

www.aop.onl/star-textile