Dr Reddy's Laboratories Limited v Controller of Patents (2022)
High Court of Delhi·10 November 2022
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Can the appropriate office of a patent application be changed once it is decided?
The appropriate office is the situs of the patent application, and under rule 4(2) once decided in respect of any proceedings shall not ordinarily be changed.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
The Patent Office, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/patent-office
1The Central Government may establish Patent Offices for the purpose of facilitating the registration of patents. There shall be a head office and other branch offices as the Central Government may specify. The head office is presently in Kolkata with branch offices in Delhi, Mumbai, and Chennai. Any reference to Patent Office shall include a branch office. (Patents Act 1970, s 2(2)(b).) Any wrongful use of words ‘Patent Office,’ including its seal, is a punishable offence. (Ibid, s 74(4).) The Patents Act and the Patent Rules employ the phrase ‘appropriate office’ while referring to the Patent Office for the proceedings under the Patents Act. (Ibid, s 121, which punishes wrongful use of the name of the Patent Office with imprisonment for a term up to six months or with fine or with both.) Rule 4 of the Patents Rules 2003 defines ‘appropriate office’ as follows:
- Appropriate office.—(1) The appropriate office of the patent office shall, for all the proceedings under the Act, be the head office of the patent office or the branch office, as the case may be, within whose territorial limits–
(a) the applicant or first mentioned applicant in case of joint applicants for a patent, normally resides or has his domicile or has a place of business or the place from where the invention actually originated; or (b) the applicant for a patent or party in a proceeding if he has no place of business or domicile in India, the address for service in India given by such applicant or party is situated.
(2) The appropriate office once decided in respect of any proceedings under the Act shall not ordinarily be changed.
2In Dr Reddy’s Laboratories v Controller of Patents (2022) the Delhi High Court held that “Rule 28 makes it clear that even if the hearing is held through video-conferencing or audio- visual communication devices from a different location, the hearing is” “deemed” “to have been held at the appropriate office. Rule 4(2) specifically provides that the appropriate office shall not ordinarily be changed once the same is decided or frozen. This obviously means that it is only in exceptional circumstances that change of appropriate office is possible under Rules.” (para 91) It noted that “In recent times, for administrative exigencies, the office of CGPDTM allocates examination of applications between Patent Offices.” and held that “Going by the principle enshrined in Rule 28 which is location-neutral, administrative exigencies would not change the appropriate office of the patent application.” and that “The appropriate office is, thus, the situs of the patent application.” (para 92)
3The Patent Office shall be staffed with the Controller, examiners and other officers as may be appointed by the Central Government. (Patents Act 1970, s 73(2).) The employees of the Patent Office shall be restricted during the period of their employment from holding any right or interest in any patent issued by the office, except by way of inheritance or bequest. (Ibid, s 75.) The officers at the Patent Office comprise of the Controller, examiners and other officers. The Controller of Patents is the chief officer of the Patent Office. The Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks appointed under s 3(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1999 shall be the Controller of Patents.
4The functions of the Controller may be discharged by the examiners or other officers upon his authorisation given from time to time by general or special order in writing. For this reason, any reference to the Controller shall include a reference to any officer discharging the functions of the Controller under s 73 of the Patents Act. (Patents Act 1970, s 2(2)(a).) The examiners and other officers shall discharge such functions of the Controller under his superintendence and directions. (Ibid, s 73(3). The Controller can give only administrative ‘superintendence and directions’ to the officers. It will not be open for the Controller to give directions as to how and in what manner the officers should decide a particular case. See Registrar of Trade Marks v Kumar Ranjan Sen AIR 1966 Cal 311, p 315, where similar power of the Registrar of Trade Marks under s 4(2) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act 1958 is discussed.) An officer or an employee of the Patent Office shall not furnish any information under the Patents Act, prepare or assist in the preparation of any document filed in the Patent Office or conduct a search in the records of the Patent Office, except with appropriate authorisation. (Patents Act 1970, s 76.)
5The Controller has the power to withdraw and transfer any matter pending before an examiner or any other officer and to deal with the same. (Ibid, s 73(4).) The reports of examiners given to the Controller shall be confidential, and shall not be open to public inspection or be published by the Controller. Such reports may be produced before a court only if the court certifies that the production or inspection is desirable in the interest of justice. (Ibid, s 144.)
6As the Controller is a creation of a statute, he cannot decide upon the validity of the rules made by the Central Government for carrying out the purposes of the Patents Act. He will not have the power to entertain matters questioning the constitutionality of any provision of the Patents Act or the Patents Rules or review any discretionary powers exercised by his official superiors. (See Gerhard Dirk’s Application (1960) RPC 1, p 13, where it was observed under the UK Patents Act 1949 that a Hearing Officer should not be called upon to consider the validity of rules issued by the Board of Trade, of which the Patent Office is one department, or to review, in relation to any discretionary powers thereby given to the Comptroller-General, their exercise, by his official superiors.) The powers of the Controller under various provisions of the Patents Act are discussed in the appropriate chapters.
7The Controller, as the authority for grant of patents, has general powers to deal with the applications pending before it. The powers of the Controller in respect of application for patents include: power to refer an application to an examiner for making report, power to refuse applications and require amendment, power to make order for division of application, power to make order on dating of application, power to make a reference, power to substitute applicants and the power to decide disputes on inventorship. (Patents Act 1970, s 12.) (Ibid, s 15.) (Ibid, s 16.) (Ibid, s 17.) (Ibid, ss 18 and 19.) (Ibid, s 20.) Apart from the above, the Controller also has the following powers under the Act and the Rules. (Ibid, s 28.)
8The Controller has general powers to amend an application and specification under the Patents Act. The Controller may also, without prejudice to the power to carry amendments under ch X of the Act, correct clerical errors in any patent, specification or other document. The power to correct clerical errors includes the power to correct entries made in the register of patents as well. (Patents Act 1970, s 78(1).) The Controller may carry out such correction either on a request in writing made by any person interested or on his own motion. (Patents Rules 2003, r 122. Such request shall be accompanied by a copy of the document highlighting the corrections clearly along with the stipulated fees.) (Patents Act 1970, s 78(2).)
9Where the Controller proposes to carry out a correction on his own motion, the Controller may give notice to the patentee, applicant or any interested person and give them an opportunity of being heard before making the correction. (Ibid, s 78(3).) Where a request is made by a person interested for the correction of an error and the Controller is of the opinion that such a correction would materially alter the meaning and scope of the document, he may require notice to the person who may be affected about the nature of the proposed correction, and the same may be published. (Patents Act 1970, s 78(4). Patents Rules 2003, r 123.) Any person interested in opposing the correction may give notice of opposition in Form 14 within three months from the date of the advertisement of the request for correction. (Patents Rules 2003, r 124(1).) The Controller may conduct the opposition as per the procedure laid down in the Act before he decides the case. (Ibid, r 124(4). See rr 58 to 63.) The Controller shall notify the corrections so made. (Ibid, r 125.)
10The Controller has the power to call for information from a patentee or licensee pertaining to the extent to which the patented invention has been commercially worked in India. (Patents Act 1970, s 146(1). Patents Rules 2003, r 131(2).) The Controller may publish the information received. Any person who refuses to furnish such information shall be punishable with fine. (Ibid, s 122(1).) If the information so furnished is false, the person shall be punishable with imprisonment up to six months or with fine or both. (Ibid, s 122(2).)
11The Controller may require any party who neither resides in India nor carries business in India to give security of costs. Such a party who intends to oppose a patent or applies for the grant of a licence may give security of costs of the proceedings. If the person fails to give such security, the Controller may treat the opposition or application as abandoned. (Patents Act 1970, s 150.)
12In respect of a class of inventions notified by the Central Government as relevant for defence purposes, the Controller may give directions for prohibiting or restricting the publication of information relating to such invention. (Ibid, s 35(1).) The Central Government shall consider whether the publication of such information would be prejudicial to the defence of India, and shall give notice to the Controller to revoke the secrecy directions if the invention is found not to be prejudicial to the defence of India. Upon the receipt of notice, the Controller shall revoke the directions and notify the applicant. (Ibid, s 35(2).)
13A patent agent registered under the Patents Act is entitled to practice before the Controller. The patent agent is also entitled to prepare documents, transact business and discharge other functions in connection with other proceedings before the Controller. (Ibid, s 127.) The Patents Act also permits an applicant of a patent to draft a specification, and to appear before the Controller in person. (Ibid, s 132(a).) An advocate within the meaning of the Advocates Act 1961 may also represent a party in any hearing before the Controller. (Ibid, s 132(b).)
14The Patent Office shall keep a record of all the patents, specifications and other documents filed before it. It shall keep a register containing the details of patents relating to grants, assignments, transmissions, licences, amendments, extensions and revocation. (Ibid, s 67(1).) The Patent Office may issue duplicate copies of the records and documents in its custody. The Patent Office shall also issue a duplicate patent upon an application stating out the circumstances in which the patent was lost or destroyed or cannot be produced. (Ibid, s 154; Patents Rules 2003, r 132.) The Controller may furnish certified copies of any entry in the register, certificates of patents, extracts from patents, specification and other public documents in the Patent Office or from the registers and other records upon a request made along with the specified fee. (Patents Rules 2003, r 133.) Under s 153, any person may make separate requests to the Controller for information with regard to each of the following: (Ibid, r 134(1).)
(a) as to when a complete specification following a provisional specification has been filed or an application for patent has been deemed to have been abandoned; (aa) as to when the information under section 8 has been filed; (b) as to when publication of application has been made under section 11A; (c) as to when an application has been withdrawn under section 11B; (d) as to when a request for examination has been made under section 11B; (e) as to when the examination report has been issued under section 12; (f) as to when an application for patent has been refused; (g) as to when a patent has been granted; (h) as to when a renewal fee has been paid; (i) as to when a term of a patent has expired or shall expire; (j) as to when an entry has been made in the register or application has been made for the making of such entry; or (k) as to when any application is made or action taken involving an entry in the register, publication in the Official Journal or otherwise, if the nature of the application or action is specified in the request.
15All granted patents should be entered into the register of patents kept at the Patent Office. The register records the name and addresses of the patentees, and contains details affecting the validity and proprietorship of patents. The register shall contain information on assignments, transmissions, licences, amendments, extensions and revocations of patents. (Patents Act 1970, s 67(1).) However, the register shall not record any notice of any trust. The register of patents shall be kept under the immediate control and management of the Controller. Falsification of entries in the register is an offence punishable under the Patents Act. (Ibid, s 119.) The register may be kept in electronic form, provided the necessary safeguards are complied with. (Ibid, s 67(4); Patents Rules 2003, r 88(3).) As such any reference to ’entry in the register’, ‘being registered or entered in the register’ and ‘rectification of the register’ would include the register kept in electronic form.
16Rectification proceedings are summary in nature. Various statutes provide for rectification of statutory registers. (See the Trade Marks Act 1999, s 57; Copyright Act 1957, s 50; Companies Act 1956, s 111(4).) Before the changes brought about by the Patents (Amendment) Act 2002, the power to rectify the register was vested with the high court. This power has now been transferred to the Appellate Board. Until the provisions pertaining to the Appellate Board come into force by notification in the Official Gazette, the power to rectify the register will remain with the high court, as it was under the Patents Act before the Patents (Amendment) Act 2002. (Patents (Amendment) Act 2005, s 1(2).) Under s 71, any aggrieved person may file an application (petition) to the high court to rectify the register. The procedure for such a petition for rectification will be governed by the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 and the relevant high court rules, whichever may be applicable.
17The following discussion is confined to the procedure that may be followed before the Appellate Board once the provisions pertaining to the Appellate Board under the Patents Act are notified. Under the Patents Act, any person may prefer an application for rectification to the Appellate Board if he is aggrieved: (Patents Act 1970, s 71(1).)
... (a) by the absence or omission from the register of any entry; or (b) by any entry made in the register without sufficient cause; or (c) by any entry wrongly remaining on the register; or (d) by any error or defect in any entry in the register.
18The High Court may order for the making, variation or deletion of any entry in the register. The High Court may decide any question that may be necessary in connection with the rectification of the register. (Ibid, s 71(2).) Under s 71, the Controller is empowered to rectify the register with respect to licences of right endorsed under s 87 of the Patents Act [as it was before the Patents (Amendment) Act 2002]. (See Imperial Chemical Industries v Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Mark (1977) AIR 1978 Cal 77, p 83, where the Calcutta High Court held of a patent deemed endorsed with the words ‘Licences of right’ that “so long as the said patent stands endorsed with the words ‘Licences of right’, as it appears was made on the 23rd Dec., 1972 and published in the official gazette, if the appellant felt aggrieved should have moved under the provisions of Section 71 of the Act and unless that was done, the entry in the register should be deemed to be correct” (para 13).) A petition for rectification can be preferred in cases where an order of revocation has been passed without giving notice to the registered proprietor. (See Re Hiralal Banjara AIR 1937 Cal 365, where the high court exercised its power to rectify the register under the Patents and Designs Act 1911.)
19As the Patents Act does not stipulate any time limit for filing an application for rectification under s 71, it is not clear whether the provisions of the Limitation Act 1963 would apply to a proceeding before the Appellate Board. But the provisions of the Limitation Act 1963 have been held to apply to a rectification proceeding before the high court, under the earlier law, where the court held that such an application has to be preferred within the three year limitation period. (See Bayer Aktiengesellschaft v Controller of Patents AIR 1982 Cal 30, p 32.)
20A certified copy of order of the High Court rectifying the register shall direct that notice of the rectification shall be served upon the Controller. On receipt of such order, the Controller shall rectify the register. (Patents Act 1970, ss 71(4), 117D(2).)
High Court of Delhi·10 November 2022
High Court of Calcutta·4 July 1977
Can a company or an unregistered person practise as a patent agent in India?
What is the evidentiary value of entries in the register of patents?
Does the Controller have the powers of a civil court in any proceeding under the Act?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/patent-office