Novartis AG v Union of India (2007)
High Court of Madras·6 August 2007
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Does the Controller have the powers of a civil court in any proceeding under the Act?
Under section 77 the Controller in any proceedings before him under the Act shall have the powers of a Civil Court, though the Code of Civil Procedure is not applicable.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
Powers of the Controller, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/controller-powers
1The Controller is the authority which grants a patent and also has the power, in certain cases, to revoke the same. The rules of procedure and evidence which apply to the civil courts will not apply to the Controller. The Central Government is empowered to make rules with regard to the matters in respect of which the Controller shall have powers of a civil court. (Patents Act 1970, s 159(2)(x).) In the course of proceedings before or after the grant, the Controller exercises various powers similar to that of a court or a tribunal. But, it is not a court or a tribunal exercising judicial functions in the strict sense of the term. In National Carbon Co Incorporated, in holding that a writ could be issued against a Controller, Panckridge J said: (Re National Carbon Co Incorporated AIR 1934 Cal 725, p 728, a case decided under the Patents and Designs Act 1911. See also Anglo French Drug Co v R D Tinaikar AIR 1959 Bom 21, (1957) 59 Bom LR 1019, where it was held that s 9 of the Bombay Pleaders Act 1920 does not apply to a proceeding before the Registrar of Trade Marks under the Trade Marks Act 1940.)
He (the Controller) is not technically a court, or a tribunal exercising judicial functions in the legal acceptation of the term, but that does not make it untrue to say that, so far as he has a duty imposed upon him to hear and determine objections to applications for leave to amend, there is a fair analogy between his position and the position of a court. The principle has been many times affirmed that when a person or body of persons, is clothed with power to determine questions, and decide issues affecting the rights of private citizen or the public, the King’s Bench Division will interfere by prohibition or certiorari to prevent the illegal exercise of such power.
2In Novartis v Union of India (2007) the Madras High Court said of the Controller that “The Statutory Authority in this case is the Patent controller. There is no doubt that he is exercising a quasi-judicial function namely, considers the patent claim application in the context of the objections received; hears parties on both sides and then passes an order, either granting the patent or rejecting the patent application, by giving reasons.” (para 10) Rejecting the attack on the amended s 3(d) as conferring uncanalised power on that authority, the Division Bench held that “if the Statutory Authority, in exercising his power, mis-directs himself; abuses his power in an arbitrary manner and passes an order, then, the same could be corrected by the hierarchy of forums provided in the Act itself in addition to the further reliefs available before the Courts of Law. When that is the position, then, we have to necessarily state that the amended section cannot be invalidated solely on the ground that there is a possibility of misusing the power.” (para 18)
3The Code of Civil Procedure 1908 is not applicable for proceedings before the Controller as held in National Carbon Co Incorporated, by Panckridge J: (Re National Carbon Co Incorporated AIR 1934 Cal 725, p 729, a case decided under the Patents and Designs Act 1911. See also Anglo French Drug Co v RD Tinaikar AIR 1959 Bom 21, (1957) 59 Bom LR 1019, where it was held that s 9 of the Bombay Pleaders Act 1920 does not apply to a proceeding before the Registrar of Trade Marks under the Trade Marks Act 1940.)
I think the answer to this is that the Code of Civil Procedure is not applicable to proceedings before the Controller. The principles underlying the Code in so far as they are principles of natural justice, must of course be observed by all authorities exercising judicial or quasi-judicial functions. How far, if at all, according to those principles the patentees have prejudiced their rights by their conduct in respect of the proposed application to the Court is for the Controller to decide.
4Thus, in exercise of his powers detailed in s 77(1), the Controller may follow the relevant principles contained in Code of Civil Procedure 1908 in summoning persons, examining the witness on oath, requiring the production of any document, receiving evidence on affidavit and issuing commissions for the examination of witnesses or documents. (See the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, O XVI.) (Ibid, O XVIII, rr 16-17.) (Ibid, O XI.) (Ibid, O XIX.) The Controller may require a party to voluntarily produce any document in its possession and may order discovery of any document if the same is required to dispose of the issues in any proceedings before him. (Ibid, O XVIII, r 19. See also O XXVI.) The Controller may also order discovery of other comparable licences for the purpose of fixing royalty. (See Petrie & Mc Naught Ltd’s Application [1966] FSR 304, pp 306-7, where discovery was ordered upon an application by the opponent requiring the applicants to disclose document in its possession. See also Temmler-werke’s Patent (1966) RPC 187; Ajinomoto’s Patent [1965] FSR 96.) The Controller has the discretion to allow amendment of pleadings. (See Smith Kline & French Laboratories Ltd’s (Cimetidine) Patents (1988) RPC 148, p 152; Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals Inc’s (Terfenadine) Patent (1991) RPC 221, p 223.) But where no counter-statement is filed by the patentee for nearly a year after the application for revocation was launched, the Controller may proceed to revoke the patent. (Flude (H) & Co (Hinckley) Ltd’s Patent (1993) RPC 197, p 199.) (See Fontaine Converting Works Incorporated’s Patent (1959) RPC 72.)
5Section 77 is not confined to the post-grant stage. In Indian Network for People living with HIV/AIDS v Union of India (2008) the Madras High Court held that “Section 77 of the said Act makes it clear that subject to any rules made, the Controller in any proceedings before him under the Act shall have the powers of a Civil Court while trying a suit under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in respect of certain matters” (para 21), and, rejecting the fourth respondent’s argument that those provisions “would only apply to proceedings before the Controller at the post grant stage” (para 22), that “Section 77 of the said Act also makes it clear that the said Section will apply to any proceedings before the Controller under the Act. Any would include all. Thus, the pre-grant opposition proceedings come within the sweep of any proceedings under Section 77 of the said Act.” (para 23) The Controller, “endowed with some of the powers of a Civil Court, and whose order or costs are executable as a decree of a Civil Court, is thus having the trappings of a Civil Court”, and “Proceeding before such an authority are obviously a quasi-judicial proceedings.” (para 24)
6The Patents Act and the Patents Rules prescribe elaborate procedure for the exercise of powers by the Controller. Where there in no provision in the Patents Act or the Rules for a party to proceeding to perform an act, file a document or produce evidence, the Controller, if he thinks it is necessary, may give notice requiring the party to perform the act, file the document or produce the evidence specified in the notice. (Patents Rules 2003, r 128(1).) The Controller may require an applicant or a party to a proceeding to submit his statement in writing, whether he desires to be heard. (Ibid, r 128(2).) The Controller has the inherent jurisdiction to prevent abuse of process by striking out or staying any proceedings in appropriate cases. (See Rhone-Poulenc SA’s (Ketoprofen) Patent (1989) RPC 570, p 573. See also Dyson Ltd’s Patent (2003) RPC 24, where the Controller stayed surrender proceedings before him pending the outcome of revocation action.)
7The residual power is not a power to do what the Act itself provides for. In Nippon Steel v Union of India (2011) the Delhi High Court held that “Rule 137 only applies to the amendment of a document for which there is no special provision in the Act. Section 57 (5) of the Act does provide for amending the priority date.”, and that “the power under Rule 137 cannot be invoked by the Office of the CoP in the circumstances of the present case to permit an amendment to a patent application that has already been” withdrawn “by operation of Section 11-B (4) of the Act.” (para 22)
8Rule 137 carries not only a power to amend but a power to undo. In NTT DoCoMo v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2014) the Madras High Court held that “the general power given under Rule 137 in favour of the Controller of patent is almost similar and identical to the power given under Section 21 of the General Clauses Act”, which “indicates that the power includes the power exercisable in the like manner and subject to the like sanction and conditions (if any), to add to, amend, vary or rescind any orders or rules, in the sense, power to do a particular thing vis-a-vis the power to undo the same.” (para 12)
9The order of the Controller awarding costs shall be executable as a decree of a civil court. (See the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, ss 35, 35A and 35B.) The Controller may award costs to the opponent in an opposition proceeding where the patentee withdraws the patent after notice of opposition is given. (Patents Act 1970, s 77(1)(e) and (2).) The award on costs should be reasonable, following the guidelines detailed in the Fourth Schedule to the Patents Rules. (Patents Rules 2003, r 63.) The Controller may also award compensatory costs in any proceeding if he is of the opinion that the proceeding was false and vexatious. (Ibid, r 136. See Stoplik Services India Pvt Ltd v Panacea Biotech Ltd (2006) 32 PTC 811 (Asst Controller).) A review of the award of costs can be requested by the relevant party, although the apportionment of costs of opposition proceedings cannot be the sole subject of an appeal. (Ibid, r 136(2). See the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, ss 35A and 35B. See also Rizla Ltd’s Application (1993) RPC 365, p 374.)
10As the Controller is not a court in the proper sense of the term, the Limitation Act 1963 will not apply for proceedings brought before him. (Applying the principles laid down in Re National Carbon Co Incorporated AIR 1934 Cal 725; Anglo French Drug Co v RD Tinaikar AIR 1959 Bom 21, (1957) 59 Bom LR 1019.)
11The Controller has general powers to extend time for doing any act or for the taking of any proceedings, if a request for extension is made before the expiry of the stipulated period. (Patents Rules 2003, r 138.)
12Under s 15 of the Patents Act, the Controller has the power to pass interim orders. Interim orders are mostly in the form of requests to amend the application, specification or any other document. (See Oertling (L)’s Application (1959) RPC 148.) Any order, either interim or final, passed under s 15 can be appealed to the Appellate Board. (Patents Act 1970, s 117A(2).)
High Court of Calcutta·26 July 1984
Can a Patent Office order be challenged in a writ petition before a High Court?
Can the appropriate office of a patent application be changed once it is decided?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/controller-powers