Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd v Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Mark (1977)
High Court of Calcutta·Sabyasachi Mukharji J·Single Judge·Decided 4 July 1977·AIR 1978 Cal 77
A right to use a patented process carries the product inevitably resulting from it, so the process claims stood endorsed with licences of right: appeal dismissed.
Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd v Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Mark, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/imperial-chemical
Summary
“This is an appeal under Section 16 of the Patents Act, 1970. This appeal is out of an order passed on 7th Jan. 1977 under Section 88(3) of the Patents Act, 1970.” (para 1) “Patent No. 77950 was granted to the appellant Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd. in respect of an invention of a catalyst which, if used, in the steam reforming of hydrocarbons achieved results which were not, according to the appellant, possible before the invention.” (para 1) “On 3rd May, 1975, the appellant received a letter from the Managing Director of Catalysts & Chemicals India (West Asia) Limited, being the second respondent herein, seeking from the appellant an agreement to enable the second respondent to undertake the manufacture in India Naptha reforming catalyst covered by the said patent.” (para 5) “On 29th March, 1976, an application was filed on behalf of the second respondent under Section 88(2) of the Patents Act, 1970 for settlement of the terms of licence under the aforesaid patent. On 30th March, 1976, the respondent No. 2 filed another application under Section 88(4) of the said Act for terms of interim licence.” (para 5) “On, 4th June 1976 an order was made by the respondent No. 1 directing that the respondent No. 2 might use and work the invention, viz. the process of manufacturing the catalyst composition comprised in Claims 19 to 24 on certain terms and conditions.” (para 5) “On 18th June 1976 the appellant moved an application under Article 226 of the Constitution on which a rule nisi was issued and interim order was passed.” (para 5)
“The main argument in support of this appeal is that the respondent No. 1 had acted in violation of the provisions of law in settling the terms of the licence for operation of the patent by the respondent No. 2.” (para 6) The Court held that “In my opinion, one cannot bifurcate, in the instant case, from the process mentioned in Claims 19 to 24 the result produced in Claims 1 to 18”, that “the claims mentioned in Claims 19 to 24 in the patent in this case were endorsable with the words ‘Licences of right’ under Section 87 of the Act, and if that was the position then the licence in respect of the user of catalyst given to the respondent No. 2 in the instant case was not in violation of the provisions of law”, and that if the appellant “felt aggrieved should have moved under the provisions of Section 71 of the Act and unless that was done, the entry in the register should be deemed to be correct.” (para 13) Although “the Controller had proceeded hastily on the 7th Jan., 1977”, “in view of the fact that the instant patent expires in July, 1977, this, in my opinion, will be an exercise in futility.” (para 14) “The appeal accordingly fails and is dismissed. Interim order, if any, granted is vacated but stay, if any, granted will continue for a fortnight. Each party will pay and bear its own costs.” (para 15)
What the court decided
- The well-settled propositions. “The following propositions, it appears to me, are well-settled: (1) The patent must be in respect of an invention and not a discovery. (2) In respect of one single invention there must be one single patent. (3) A patent may be in respect of a substance or in respect of a process. (4) But it is not possible to bifurcate a patent and state that one relates to the substance and the other to the process. (5) In order to have a complete patent, the specifications and the claims must be clearly and distinctly mentioned. (6) It is the claims, and claims alone which constitute the patent.” (para 12)
- Process claims and their product. “It appears that the claims 19 to 24 were related to process of preparing steam reforming catalyst claimed in the claim Nos. 1 to 18. The processes claimed and illustrated in the examples are essentially chemical processes and involved at least one chemical reaction. The processes claimed in Claims 25 to 39 are steam re-forming of hydro carbons using the said catalyst, are also chemical process. In my opinion, one cannot bifurcate, in the instant case, from the process mentioned in Claims 19 to 24 the result produced in Claims 1 to 18.” (para 13)
- The right to the end product. “A person having the right to use a process patented under the Indian Patents and Designs Act, 1911 has also the right to make use, sell and distribute the product of the process if the product is inevitably the result of the process followed. If one has a right to use the process, then one acquires the right to use the end product unless the end product is different and separate from the process followed.” (para 13)
- Endorsement under Section 87. “Judged from the aforesaid point of view, in my opinion, the claims mentioned in Claims 19 to 24 in the patent in this case were endorsable with the words ‘Licences of right’ under Section 87 of the Act, and if that was the position then the licence in respect of the user of catalyst given to the respondent No. 2 in the instant case was not in violation of the provisions of law.” (para 13)
- The entry in the register. “Furthermore, in any event so long as the said patent stands endorsed with the words ‘Licences of right’, as it appears was made on the 23rd Dec., 1972 and published in the official gazette, if the appellant felt aggrieved should have moved under the provisions of Section 71 of the Act and unless that was done, the entry in the register should be deemed to be correct.” (para 13)
- A deeming provision and rectification. Of the argument “that Section 87 made a deeming provision and there was no scope of making any correction or entry in the register, as was done in this case”, the Court held: “I am unable to accept the contention. It is true that the law deems certain situation in this case apart from any action taken, but in order that such a situation is given practical effect to a rectification or a consequential correction in the register would be necessary as was done in this case for the benefit of public knowledge. There was nothing illegal or improper in that.” (para 13)
- Procedure. Setting aside an ex parte order. “The appellant instead of moving for setting aside the ex parte order under Rule 115 of the Patent Rules, which dealt with similar powers as under Order 9, Rule 13, of the Code of Civil Procedure has made and preferred this appeal. Of course there is one justification for the appellant in preferring this appeal because the appellant was here challenging the very basis of the right of endorsement of licences as of right.” (para 14)
- A hasty hearing and futility. “As I have noticed that on the final occasion the appellant did not submit any objections, therefore, even though there might have been some cause for grievance for the petitioner it is not possible to interfere with the impugned order.” “But it appears to me that the Controller had proceeded hastily on the 7th Jan., 1977 and I would have set aside the order and given the appellant an opportunity to agitate its grievances on the points about the settlement of the terms of the licence under which the respondent No. 2 would work the patent in spite of the fact that the appellant had not preferred an application for review under Rule 115 of the Patent Rules, but in view of the fact that the instant patent expires in July, 1977, this, in my opinion, will be an exercise in futility. In that view of the matter, I decline to interfere with the order passed by the Controller.” (para 14)
- Disposition. “The appeal accordingly fails and is dismissed. Interim order, if any, granted is vacated but stay, if any, granted will continue for a fortnight. Each party will pay and bear its own costs.” (para 15)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 27 October 2026.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Compulsory Licences: The Scheme
Process Patents and Product Patents
The Patent Office
The Register of Patents
Terms of a Compulsory Licence
Case page · Page updated 18 November 2026
www.aop.onl/imperial-chemical