Guest Keen Williams Ltd v Controller of Patents and Designs (1984)
High Court of Calcutta·Padma Khastgir J·Single Judge·Decided 26 July 1984·AIR 1985 Cal 334
No party may claim cross-examination or oral evidence before the Controller as of right, and his reasoned interlocutory refusal in an opposition survives Article 226: petition rejected.
Guest Keen Williams Ltd v Controller of Patents and Designs, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/guest-keen
Summary
The petitioner “applied for grant of a patent in favour of the petitioner in regard to the said adapter, being application for patent No. 145211”, a “rail clip adapter for the purpose of fitting in the railway track assembly”, and “the Research, Designs & Standards Organisation of the Ministry of Railways, filed an opposition to the said application on 31st Jan., 1979 inter alia on the ground of prior public knowledge and prior public use in India of the petitioner’s invention as claimed” (para 1). At the hearing, “after the RDSO” (“Research, Designs and Standards Organisation”) “closed its case, it was submitted on behalf of the, petitioner that the affidavit of Himangshu Bhusan Pal be taken off the file and leave be granted to the petitioner to file the affidavit of one Suraj Mohan Khorana”, with “further leave to cross-examine the said Himangshu Bhusan Pal” (para 1). “The Deputy Controller of Patents & Designs rejected the aforesaid contentions of the petitioner”, and the petitioner “moved an application before this High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging the said order” (para 1).
The Court held that under Section 79 “no party can claim as a matter of right to call for evidence, cross-examine witnesses and also insist on oral evidence being taken unless the Controller thinks it fit to do so” and that “once such discretion had been exercised by the Controller, this Court would not sit over appeal from the decision of the Controller” (para 4). Finding that “no ground has been made out for interference by this Court with the order passed in interlocutory stage by the Controller” (para 4), it concluded: “Under these circumstances, this Court is of the view that this Court should not interfere with the interlocutory order passed by the respondent. As a result, this application is rejected.” (para 5)
What the court decided
- Evidence before the Controller. “Section 79 provides that in any proceeding before the Controller evidence shall be given by affidavit in the absence of directions by the Controller to the contrary. In a case in which the Controller thinks it right to do so, he may take oral evidence in lieu of or in addition to evidence by affidavit or may allow any party to be cross-examined on the contents of his affidavit. Under the circumstances no party can claim as a matter of right to call for evidence, cross-examine witnesses and also insist on oral evidence being taken unless the Controller thinks it fit to do so.” (para 4)
- Writ against an interlocutory order. “Under the circumstances once such discretion had been exercised by the Controller, this Court would not sit over appeal from the decision of the Controller. By way of interlocutory application this Court should not interfere and exercise its writ jurisdiction, more so in a case of issuing a writ of certiorari, unless a strong case had been made out, the party should be relegated to adhere to the alternative remedy provided for.” (para 4)
- No ground for certiorari. “There had been no averment in the petition itself of any instant injury which should call for this Court’s exercise of the jurisdiction under the writ of certiorari.” “From the averments made in the petition it would not indicate that the order made by the Deputy Controller of Patents & Designs was perverse or the reasons given by such authority were unreasonable or that there was want of jurisdiction or there was refusal or that there was illegality complained of, nor there had been any breach of any fundamental principle of justice.” (para 4)
- Points open at the final hearing. “Under the circumstances this Court should not interfere with an order passed on an intealocutory application, inasmuch as all the points raised by the petitioner could also be gone into and decided by the Controller at the time of final hearing.” (para 4)
- A reasoned discretionary refusal. “Undoubtedly the Controller of Patents and Designs have powers, similar to the powers given under the Civil Procedure Code, to issue subpoena to witnesses on the application of the parties. But it is the discretionary power given to the Controller and such discretion having been used and the reasons having been given for such refusal on the part of the Controller, this Court should not interfere, sitting over an appeal, with such decision of the Controller.” (para 4)
- The late objection. “Even if such objection was taken at the time of the hearing, the Controller had the discretion to reject it on the facts and circumstances of the case. Apart from that an affidavit of Mr. Khorana sought to be relied upon by the applicant, although affirmed one year earlier, had not been filed by the petitioner in time.” (para 4)
- The alternative remedy. “In any event the petitioner was entitled not only to appeal from the order, as provided under the Act itself and the rules framed thereunder but is also entitled to challenge the final decision of the respondent.” (para 4)
- Disposition. “As a result, this application is rejected. All interim orders are vacated. There will however be a stay of operation of this order for a fortnight from date.” (para 5)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 27 October 2026.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Powers of the Controller
Writ Jurisdiction in Patent Matters
Case page · Page updated 17 November 2026
www.aop.onl/guest-keen