Doctrine page

Appeals in Opposition

Can an unsuccessful opponent appeal the Controller's order in an opposition?

Under section 117A the opponent does not have a right to appeal under the Act, the remedy in the case of an unsuccessful opposition being post-grant opposition or revocation proceedings.

Doctrine last updated on 14 November 2026

Cite this page

Appeals in Opposition, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/opposition-appeals

1Appeals become inevitable as the commercial value of inventions rarely allow the parties to settle with the decision of the Controller. The TRIPS Agreement provides for appeals from opposition proceedings. (See the TRIPS Agreement, art 62.5.) In the EPO, appeals are preferred against a substantial number of opposition decisions. The available data indicates that every third case decided by the Opposition Board results in an appeal. As the decisions of the Controller are subject to appeal, opposition proceedings in India must be conducted keeping the possibility of appeal in the background. In an appeal, the Appellate Board has lesser opportunity to re-examine the patent than in opposition. Appellate proceedings should not be regarded as a mere continuation of first instance proceedings. The function of an appeal is to give a judicial decision upon the correctness of a separate earlier decision given at the first instance. (See T34/90 Unilever/Viscosity Reduction(Opposition by Henkel) [1992] OJ EPO 454, [1992] EPOR 466.) The purpose of appeal proceedings is mainly to give the losing party the possibility of challenging the decision of the Controller on its merits. It is a judicial procedure in contrast to the administrative character of the opposition procedure, and by its nature, is less investigative. (See G09/91, G10/91 Rohm & Haas/Power to Examine [1993] OJ EPO 408, [1993] EPOR 485.)

2Appeals offer limited scope for expanding the grounds of opposition. In India, the decisions of a higher judicial authority have binding effect. In contrast, the decisions of the EPO are binding only is certain cases and the Boards are normally bound by the provisions of the EPC. (A Board of Appeal decision is binding on the first instance department [art 111(2) EPC] and an Enlarged Board of Appeal decision is binding on the Board of Appeal that referred a question for decision [arts 112(1)(a) and (3) EPC].) It would be advisable to prefer a cross appeal where there is scope for improvement in the decision. (EPC, art 23(3).) The party winning in the opposition may have procured a reasonably favourable decision, yet filing a cross appeal can explore the chance of procuring a better decision. Appeals are entertained usually on questions of law. (See General Electric Co’s Application (1964) RPC 413; Imperial Chemical Industries (Haggis’) Application (1975) RPC 403, p 419.) Section 117A of the Patents Act provides for appeals to the Appellate Board from decisions of the Controller. The order of the Controller in opposition proceedings may direct any one of the following two courses: (Patents Act, s 25(4).)

(1) grant the patent (consequent to pre-grant opposition), maintain or amend the patent already granted (consequent to post-grant opposition). Both the above outcomes are considered favourable to the patentee; or (2) reject the application (consequent to pre-grant opposition) or revoke the patent (consequent to post-grant opposition).

3An applicant has a right to appeal to the Appellate Board from an order of the Controller refusing the application or requiring the application to be amended." (Ibid, s 117A.) “Section 25 does not state the details of the order that may be passed by the Controller consequent to a pre-grant opposition. The details of an order passed by the Controller on an application are contained in s 15. (See Danieli A C Officine Maccaniche v Controller of Patents & Designs (1999), (2000) 1 Cal LT 7 (HC).) Section 15 illustrates the two options that the Controller may adopt with respect to an application before him. The Controller may ‘refuse the application or may require the application…to be amended’. (Patents Act 1970, s 15.) These two options coincide with what a Controller can do consequent to a pre-grant opposition detailed in r 55(5) of the Patents Rules. An order passed by the Controller pursuant to pre-grant opposition is an order passed under s 15 which can be a subject matter of appeal under s 117A(2). In UCB Farchim v Cipla (2010) the Delhi High Court held that “where the pre-grant opposition is accepted and the grant of patent is refused by the Controller, although the decision is one taken under Section 25(1), it is in effect a decision relatable to and under Section 15 of the Patents Act” (para 22), and that “where the grant of patent is refused by the Controller after accepting a pre-grant opposition under Section 25(1) of the Patents Act, the applicant for a patent will have a remedy by way of an appeal to the IPAB under Section 117A of the Patents Act.” (para 23) “The opponent, however, does not have a right to appeal under the Act.” (See the TRIPS Agreement, art 62.5.) In UCB Farchim the Court held that “no appeal is maintainable in this Court or the IPAB at the instance of APL against the Controller’s order” (para 31). “The remedy in the case of an unsuccessful opposition would be to institute post-grant opposition or revocation proceedings.” The Court held that “their remedy against the rejection of their pre-grant opposition is to file a post-grant opposition under Section 25(2) and await the decision of the Controller.” (para 18)

4According to s 117A(2), an order passed in a post-grant opposition under s 25(4) can be a subject matter of an appeal to the High Court. It may appear that any order passed by the Controller ’to maintain or to amend or to revoke the patent’ may be taken before the Appellate Board on appeal. But if post-grant opposition is viewed as one of the many challenge mechanisms provided under the Act, there would appear to be a conflict between an appeal by an unsuccessful opponent under s 25(4) of the Act and a petition for revocation made before the Appellate Board pursuant to s 64. The conflict manifests from the fact that both the proceedings come before the Appellate Board on more or less similar grounds. Moreover, both the proceedings can be initiated at the same time, ie, after the grant. It would not be practicable for the Appellate Board to entertain an appeal from a post-grant opposition and later receive a petition for revocation from the same opponent if the appeal fails. This would lead to an abuse of process. The TRIPS Agreement provides some guidance in this regard as it states that there shall be no obligation on the members to provide an opportunity for review of decisions in cases of unsuccessful opposition or administrative revocation, provided that the grounds for such procedures can be the subject of invalidation procedures. (Ibid.) It is submitted that if a party prefers an appeal against a decision in a post-grant opposition, it would not be open for the party to initiate a revocation proceeding before the Appellate Board raising the same grounds. However, there may be instances where both proceedings can be maintained in parallel on separate grounds. (For instance, the Patents Act 1970, s 25(2)(i) contains a special ground for opposition which does not figure in the grounds of revocation under s 64.) An opponent in appeal may present fresh reasons unconnected with the grounds of the decision below if they fall within the same grounds of opposition. (See T611/91 Mitsui/Ethylene Copolymer [1991] EPOR 481, p 483.)

5In J. Mitra v Assistant Controller of Patents & Designs (2008) the Supreme Court held that “In the present case, the Legislature intended to provide for two types of scrutiny followed by one statutory appeal to the Appellate Board against ‘post-grant proceedings’”, that “The Legislature intended to have a dichotomy between ‘pre-grant opposition’ and ‘post-grant opposition’”, and that “The Legislature intended to obliterate appeal from ‘pre-grant proceedings’, which existed earlier. However, it was left to the Executive to bring the enacted law into force vide notification.” (para 23) It held that “The Appellate Board after 2.4.07 is entitled to hear appeals only arising from orders passed by the Controller under Section 25(4), i.e., in cases of orders passed in ‘post-grant opposition’.” (para 24)

6An appeal may be preferred not only from a final decision but also from any interlocutory order which may lead up to the final decision, for such interim decisions are a part of the decision of the whole case. (Robertson’s Application (1930) 47 RPC 215, p 220.) For instance, an order of the Controller requiring the amendment of an application under s 15 can be appealed to the High Court. (Patents Act 1970, s 117A(2).) Under s 15, the Controller may require an application, specification or other documents to be amended to his satisfaction before he proceeds further. Such an order will be an interim order as the Controller may refuse the application on the failure of the applicant to carry the amendment.

7In Guest Keen Williams v Controller of Patents and Designs (1984), refusing a writ of certiorari against the Deputy Controller’s interlocutory rulings on evidence in an opposition, the Calcutta High Court recorded that “all the points raised by the petitioner could also be gone into and decided by the Controller at the time of final hearing” and that “In any event the petitioner was entitled not only to appeal from the order, as provided under the Act itself and the rules framed thereunder but is also entitled to challenge the final decision of the respondent.” (para 4)

8New evidence may be appreciated on appeal if leave is procured to produce the same. The general rule with regard to admissibility of new evidence is that it would be allowed in appeal if the new evidence was not in the possession of the opponent at the time of the hearing at the first instance and that the opponent could not have obtained such evidence through the exercise of reasonable diligence. (See Toyo Tsushinki Kabushiki Kaisha’s Application (1962) RPC 9, p 13. See also Gebhardt’s Patent (1992) RPC 1, pp 13-14, where the new evidence was refused on the ground that the stated importance of the new evidence was not an exceptional reason for admitting it.) No examination of witnesses will be allowed in appeal where the choice to examine was not exercised at the first instance proceedings. (Sainsbury J Ltd’s Application [1981] FSR 406, p 408 (CA).) The matter may be decided entirely on written evidence. (See Pickett’s Application (1999) RPC 337, pp 342-343.) The appellate body would reverse the finding of the first instance forum only if it is of the opinion that it might have come to a different conclusion if it had tried the case at the first instance. (Owens-Corning Fibreglas Corpn’s Patent (1972) RPC 684, p 689.) Normally, no new ground will be entertained on appeal that was not raised at the first instance. (Poysha Industries v Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs (1974) AIR 1975 Cal 178.) On a contention that the subject-matter was no invention at all, raised for the first time in appeal, the Calcutta High Court said “This appears to me to be a new ground altogether and it seems that under the earlier Act the application could not have been opposed on such a ground.” (para 9) It added that “No authority was cited on behalf of the appellants to show that the new ground urged in this appeal could be agitated under the specific ground of prior public user as laid down in Section 9 (d) of the old Act.” (para 11) It made clear that it decided nothing on the point itself: “I make it quite clear that I have come to no finding whether this particular container closure amounts to an invention within the meaning of the Indian Patents and Designs Act, 1911, or the Patents Act, 1970.” (para 15)

9The Controller should make it clear to the applicant/patentee the course to be adopted after the withdrawal of the opposition. If the Controller feels that the opposition should proceed despite the withdrawal, he should indicate the same to the applicant/patentee who may challenge such decision. (Tea Research Association’s Application (1971) RPC 72, p 78.) The withdrawal of opposition does not automatically conclude the opposition proceedings. There is no provision under the Patents Act or the Patents Rules to withdraw. The Controller may continue the opposition in public interest and must be wary of collusion between the parties. Withdrawal merely means that the opponent is no longer interested in pursuing the opposition. A withdrawal should not be construed as an invalidation of the grounds of opposition already raised. The Controller may require the opponent to give reasons for the withdrawal.

10The opponent may write to the Controller indicating its intention to withdraw from the proceedings. The Controller has to consider whether the request to withdraw should be allowed or whether the opposition should continue in public interest. (General Motors Corpn (Turney & Barr’s) Application (1976) RPC 659, p 669.) Due caution should be exercised in taking a decision to withdraw opposition as it can have repercussions in the future. Once an opponent withdraws his opposition, he jeopardises his right to institute a revocation proceeding and even his right to counter-claim revocation in an infringement suit. If the withdrawal results in a settlement by the contesting parties that the patent would continue, then such withdrawal can have the effect of a compromise.

11As stated earlier, appeal proceedings have been identified as principally judicial proceedings as contrasted to the administrative nature of opposition proceedings. As a result, the appeal scrutiny is limited to reviewing the correctness of the earlier decision. A pending appeal in opposition proceedings can be transferred to another party together with the business or part of the undertaking in the interest of which the appeal was filed. (See T659/92 Schweisfurth/Transfer of Opposition [1996] EPOR 314, p 316.)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases on this page

Case page

UCB Farchim SA v Cipla Ltd (2010)

High Court of Delhi·8 February 2010

Case page

Guest Keen Williams Ltd v Controller of Patents and Designs (1984)

High Court of Calcutta·26 July 1984

Case page

Danieli A C Officine Maccaniche SpA v Controller of Patents & Designs (1999)

High Court of Calcutta·28 June 1999

Case page

J. Mitra & Co Pvt Ltd v Assistant Controller of Patents & Designs (2008)

Supreme Court of India·21 August 2008

See also

Doctrine page

The Nature of Pre-grant Opposition

Is pre-grant opposition under section 25(1) an adversarial proceeding between the opponent and the applicant?

Doctrine page

Appeals from the Controller

Can an order of the Patent Controller be appealed to the High Court?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/opposition-appeals