Huhtamaki Oyj v Controller of Patents (2023)
High Court of Delhi·C. Hari Shankar J·Single Judge·Decided 26 May 2023·2023 SCC OnLine Del 3272
An order refusing a patent application by merely reproducing the hearing notice is an abdication of duty: refusal quashed, remanded de novo, with directions for reasoned orders.
Huhtamaki Oyj v Controller of Patents, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/huhtamaki
Summary
On the background of the case, the Court noted that “I have, before me, yet another order passed by an Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, whereby Application No. 6727/DELNP/2014, filed by the appellant, seeking registration of a patent, stands rejected, without even a word of independent reasoning, merely reproducing the contents of the hearing notice issued to the appellant.” (para 1) On that application, “First Examination Report (FER) was issued to the appellant on 28th May 2019. The appellant submitted its response to the FER on 19th November 2019, whereafter, hearing notice dated 16th July 2020 was issued to the appellant by the Assistant Controller, fixing hearing in the matter on 6th August 2020.” (para 2) The appellant “responded to the aforesaid objections vide letter dated 21st August 2020” (para 3), and “The impugned order has come to be passed three days later on 24th August 2020.” (para 4) The claim was to an “essentially biobased and optionally biodegradable thermoformable Composition” (para 5), and the Assistant Controller concluded that “the application filed in pursuance thereof, does not comply with the requirements of the section 2(1)(ja) of The Patents Act, 1970. Hence, the application no. 6727/DELNP/2014 is refused u/s 15 of the Patents Act, 1970.” (para 5)
On merits the Bench held that “It is obvious that the Assistant Controller has completely abdicated the duty cast on her to dispassionately consider the petitioner’s application seeking a grant of patent.” (para 7) It found in the order “the apparently endemic problem in the office of the Controller of Patents and Designs, reflected in order after order coming before this Court, to reject patent applications by merely reproducing the objections issued to the proposed patentee, without even a word of reference to the reply of the patentee filed in response thereto, and totally without any application of mind whatsoever” (para 8), and reiterated “that refusal of a patent application is a serious matter”, since “even if the patent ultimately comes to be granted, the time that has been spent in prosecuting the application, and challenging unreasoned orders of rejection which are passed, leaves hardly any residual life for the patent.” (para 11) Being “constrained to issue the following directions” (para 12), the Bench directed that “Every order which either” ... “shall be reasoned and speaking, and shall deal systematically and sequentially with each objection that requires consideration” (para 12), that the directions “shall be strictly complied with” (para 13), and that continued default “may invite disciplinary action.” (para 14) “The impugned order is quashed and set aside.” (para 16) “Application No. 6727/DELNP/2014 filed by the appellant is remanded for de novo consideration.” (para 17) “This appeal stands allowed in the aforesaid terms.” (para 21)
What the court decided
- Reproduction of the hearing notice. Comparing “the impugned order with the hearing notice dated 16th July 2020”, the Bench found that “the first three pages of the impugned order” ... “are a verbatim reproduction of the objections contained in the hearing notice dated 16th July 2020”, and that “Thereafter, the impugned order once again reproduces the entire content of the hearing notice, already reproduced in the first three pages of the impugned order” (para 6)
- Abdication of the duty. The Bench held: “It is obvious that the Assistant Controller has completely abdicated the duty cast on her to dispassionately consider the petitioner’s application seeking a grant of patent.” (para 7)
- An endemic problem. “This is yet another order which reflects the apparently endemic problem in the office of the Controller of Patents and Designs, reflected in order after order coming before this Court, to reject patent applications by merely reproducing the objections issued to the proposed patentee, without even a word of reference to the reply of the patentee filed in response thereto, and totally without any application of mind whatsoever.” (para 8) The Bench added: “I am unable to understand why adjudicating officers in the patent office have apparently made a habit to pass orders which merely cut and paste paragraphs from the record before the officer, and reflect no application of mind at all to the case that the applicant seeks to set up.” (paras 8, 10)
- Why refusal is a serious matter. “For the end time, this Court is reiterating that refusal of a patent application is a serious matter. A patent, once granted, survives only for 20 years. The statutory provisions reckon this period from the date of application for grant of the patent, and not from the date of grant. If patent applications are to be decided laconically, as has been done in the present case, patent applicants will have to keep knocking at the doors of the Court, wasting their time in unnecessary litigation. In such circumstances, even if the patent ultimately comes to be granted, the time that has been spent in prosecuting the application, and challenging unreasoned orders of rejection which are passed, leaves hardly any residual life for the patent.” (para 11)
- The directions on reasoned orders. Being “constrained to issue the following directions”, the Bench directed that “Every order which either” “rejects an application seeking grant of a patent” or “accepts, or rejects, any pre- or post-grant opposition to such applications, shall be reasoned and speaking, and shall deal systematically and sequentially with each objection that requires consideration, whether contained in the FER” (“First Examination Report”) “, or the hearing notice, or in any pre- or post-grant opposition, and provide reasons as to why the objection is sustained or rejected.”; that “If there is no pre- or post-grant opposition to the patent, and objections are raised only by the office of the Controller itself, in the FER or Hearing Notice, and the reply of the applicant in response thereto is found to be worthy of acceptance, then, too, the order granting the patent should briefly state why the applicant’s reply is accepted, as this would facilitate any post-grant opponent,” “who seeks to oppose the grant of the patent, or seek its revocation, after the patent is granted.”; and that “The requirement of a reasoned and speaking order would obviously not apply if the patent, as sought, is granted, and there is no objection in the FER or hearing notice, or pre- or post-grant opposition thereto.” (para 12)
- Compliance and publicity. “These directions shall be strictly complied with. They would be duly publicized in the office of the Controller General of Patents and Designs, whether by display on the official Notice Board or otherwise. It may be advisable for the Controller General to circulate these directions by way of an official Circular so that they percolate to all adjudicating authorities in his office.” (para 13)
- Disciplinary action. “If, despite these directions, adjudicating officers dealing with applications for grant of patents, or oppositions thereto, continue to pass orders such as one under challenge in the present appeal, it may invite disciplinary action. What has happened, has happened.” The Bench added that “The learned Controller General is, however, requested to take steps to ensure and, if necessary, to properly instruct adjudicating authorities working under him, to ensure that such orders are not repeatedly passed and this Court, in turn, is not faced with the unhappy task of passing orders such as this.” (para 14)
- Obiter. Training in writing orders. “This Court is unaware whether adjudicating officers in the office of the Controller General of Patents, who deal with applications seeking grant of patents and oppositions thereto, are imparted any training on how to write quasi-judicial orders. Stakes in such matters are so high, and the impact on public interest so great, that such training is imperative.” (para 15)
- Disposition. “The impugned order is quashed and set aside.” (para 16) “Application No. 6727/DELNP/2014 filed by the appellant is remanded for de novo consideration.” (para 17) “This appeal stands allowed in the aforesaid terms.” (paras 16–17, 21)
- Remand to a different officer. “The learned Controller General is requested to ensure that the application is taken up by an officer other than the one who has passed the impugned order.” (para 18) “The designated adjudicating officer is directed to grant opportunity of hearing to the appellant on 5th June 2023. Consequent thereupon, let a final order be passed by the concerned adjudicating authority within a maximum period of three weeks from the date of hearing.” (paras 18–19)
- What the fresh order must show. “It is expected that the impugned order would deal with all submissions raised by the appellant in the response to the FER as well as the response to the hearing notice and any other oral submissions which the appellant may desire to advance during the hearing, and would also reflect due application of mind.” (para 20)
Subsequent treatment
Followed in ITC Limited v The Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (Delhi HC, Jyoti Singh J, 12 January 2026), where the Court held that “This Court in Synthes (supra) and Huhtamaki Oyj (supra) has seriously condemned the manner in which the Controllers are passing the orders relating to patents.” (para 27)
No further appeal traced as of 28 October 2026.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Appeals from the Controller
Powers of the Controller
Term of a Patent
Case page · Page updated 5 November 2026
www.aop.onl/huhtamaki