Doctrine page

Who May Apply

Who may apply for a patent in India, the inventor, an assignee or a company?

Under section 6 an application may be made by the true and first inventor, who must be a natural person, or by his assignee or legal representative.

Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026

Cite this page

Who May Apply, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/who-may-apply

1The Patents Act does not define the expression ’true and first inventor’. It merely excludes the first importer of an invention into India, and a person to whom an invention is first communicated from outside India, from the ambit of the expression. (Patents Act 1970, s 2(1)(y).) The UK Patents Act, however, does define the inventor as ’the actual deviser of the invention’. (UK Patents Act 1977, s 7(3).) This would mean a person who first made the invention and who had first applied for the patent. A person will not be regarded as an inventor merely because he contributes to the claim. An inventor is a person who contributes to the formulation of the inventive concept. (University of Southampton’s Applications [2004] EWHC 2107 (Pat), (2005) RPC 11, para 39.) An antecedent worker, who comes up with or communicates the idea consisting of all the elements of the claim, even though it is just an idea at that stage, would qualify for an inventor. (Stanelco Fibre Optics Ltd’s Applications [2004] EWHC 2263, (2005) RPC 15, para 14.)

2The Patents Act requires the true and first inventor to be a natural person. Many of the forms in second schedule to the Patents Rules require the disclosure of the name of the natural person who has signed them. (See, for instance, Patents Rules 2003, Forms 13 and 14.) This requirement is equivalent to the disclosure of the name of the ’true and first inventor’. Juristic entitles like corporations, institutions and companies can, at best, be an assignee or a joint applicant along with the true and first inventor.

3As the Patents Act follows the first-to-file system, in cases where two persons simultaneously make the same invention and neither of them uses or discloses the invention prior to making the application, the person who first applies for the patent will be considered as the ’true and first inventor’ even if the other would have actually made the invention prior in time. The first-to-file system is based on the reasoning that the person who files the application first makes a contribution to the public by showing them how to practice the invention. (See Canadian General Electric Co Ltd v Fada Radio Ltd AIR 1930 PC 1, p 5, [1930] AC 97, p 103, (1930) 47 RPC 69; Bombay Agarwal Co Akola v Ramchand Diwanchand AIR 1953 Nag 154, pp 162-3.) Thus, a patent is granted under the Patents Act to a person who approaches the Patent Office first for a patent. The grant confers an exclusive right to monopolise the invention which is given in lieu of the disclosure of the invention. So, the disclosure made to the Patent Office is a condition that entitles one for a grant. This puts a person, who may have made the invention first but did not approach the Patent Office with an application for grant, in a position where it would be difficult to prove himself as the ’true and first inventor’, except in cases where the invention is wrongfully obtained from him.

4For this reason, the patent is granted to the person who finds out ‘something which has not been found out by other people’. (Pope Appliance Corpn v Spanish River Pulp and Paper Mills Ltd [1929] AC 269, p 280, AIR 1929 PC 38, p 43, (1929) 46 RPC 23.) The person to whom an idea occurred will not be the true and first inventor, unless he had also reduced the idea to a definite and practical shape. (Permutit Co v Borrowman (1926) 43 RPC 356, p 359, [1926] 4 DLR 285.) The name of the true and first inventor shall be disclosed in every application. Where the applicant is not the true and first inventor, the application shall contain a declaration that the applicant believes the person so named to be the true and first inventor. (Patents Act 1970, s 7(3).)

5As the right to apply is an assignable right, the assignee of the true and first inventor may also apply for the patent. (See Patents Act 1970, s 2(1)(ab). An assignee includes an assignee of the assignee and the legal representative of a deceased assignee.) There is no restriction as to who may be an assignee; even a foreigner can be an assignee. (But the applicant must be a national of India or of a convention country.) An assignee can either be a natural person or a legal person such as a registered company, research organisation, educational institution or government. Though assignments are usually done in writing, the Patents Act or the Patents Rules do not preclude an oral assignment. No procedural formalities are stipulated under the Patents Act for an assignment to be valid. Where the application is made by an assignee of the true and first inventor, every application must contain a declaration by the applicant stating, among other things, the following: (Patents Rules 2003, Form 1.)

(1) that the applicant is in possession of the invention; (2) that there is no lawful ground of objection to the grant of the patent to the applicant; and (3) that the applicant is the assignee or legal representative of the true and first inventor.

6The assignee should also furnish the proof of the right to make the application either along with the application, or within a period of six months after the filing of such application. (Patents Act 1970, s 7(2); Patents Rules 2003, r 10.) The above six-month period in case of an application corresponding to an international application designating India shall be calculated from the actual date on which the application is filed in India. (Patents Rules 2003, r 10.) The assignee has to state the name of the true and first inventor. Any application made without making the true and first inventor a party is void. Such an omission cannot be cured by amendment. (See Edward Carter’s Application (1932) 49 RPC 403. In this case, the application was made by the nominee of the inventor.)

7A company or a firm may also apply for a patent as the assignee of the true and first inventor. (Shining Industries v Shri Krishna Industries AIR 1975 All 231, p 234.) Though a body corporate does not have the capacity to invent, the rights of the true and first inventor may be assigned to it. As stated above, a person entitled to apply for a patent under the Patents Act includes the government. (Patents Act 1970, s 2(1)(s).) But a member of an official commission or committee investigating into the patent cannot take out a patent for the results of an official investigation belonging absolutely to the state. (Patterson v Gaslight and Coke Co (1875-76) LR 2 Ch D 812, pp 832-833 (CA).)

8In Shining Industries v Shri Krishna Industries (1974) the Allahabad High Court held that “if it was stated in the application moved on behalf of the respondent firm, of which Bodhraj Anand was a partner, that the invention was assigned to the respondent firm, it was a valid assignment within the meaning of Sub-section (3) of Section 3” (para 10), and observed that “from the cases cited on other points it is apparent that patents have been granted in favour of firms.” (para 15)

9The right to apply for a patent is a continuing right which will pass on to the legal representatives of the any deceased person who was entitled to make such an application. A legal representative is a person who in law represents the estate of a deceased person. (Patents Act 1970, s 2(1)(k).) The legal representative should file the death certificate and other documents as proof of right.

Provisions and topics

Provisions

Cases on this page

Case page

Bombay Agarwal Co v Ramchand Diwanchand (1952)

High Court of Nagpur·13 February 1952

Case page

Shining Industries v Shri Krishna Industries (1974)

High Court of Allahabad·3 May 1974

See also

Doctrine page

The True and First Inventor

Who is a true and first inventor under section 2(1)(y) of the Patents Act?

Doctrine page

Proof of Right

When must an assignee furnish proof of right to apply for a patent in India?

Doctrine page

Assignment

What does it take to assign a patent in India?

Doctrine page

Co-ownership of a Patent

How is a patent shared between co-owners in India?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/who-may-apply