Doctrine page

Unity of Invention

Must plural inventions appear in the claims for a divisional application under section 16?

A claim shall relate to a single invention or a single inventive concept under section 10(5), and plurality of inventions is tested based upon the disclosures made in the specification.

Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026

Cite this page

Unity of Invention, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/unity-of-invention

1Section 10(5) of the Patents Act states that a claim of a complete specification shall relate to a single invention or a ‘single inventive concept’. The construction of the claims will be essential to determine whether a prior claim could properly be regarded as the summation of a number of notional separate claims to alternative ingredients in a manner of manufacture or a claim to a generalised manner of manufacture in which the identity of the ingredients, save in the broad sense of inclusion in a chemical classification, was not essential. (Merck & Co (Macek’s) Patent [1966] FSR 381, p 386, (1967) RPC 157.) In cases involving chemical patents, the courts have held that whether a general formula can be regarded as a convenient way of specifying a number of alternatives which would occur to the reader on seeing the formula must be a matter of degree. (Allen and Hanburys Ltd (Hayes’) Application (1977) RPC 113, p 117.) As a matter of construction, if the courts perceive that any particular compound would, as a matter of course, occur to the reader as being included within and disclosed by the formula, then it would be proper to notionally ‘rewrite the claim’ so as to include such a compound specifically within its scope. (Ibid.) The issue of notionally splitting the claims in a specification arises in determining obviousness. (Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd (Howe’s) Application (1977) RPC 121.)

2In Syngenta v Controller of Patents and Designs (Delhi, 13 October 2023) the Division Bench found “no justification to read Section 16 of the Act as prescribing that plural inventions must be found or stand reflected in the claims” (para 21), and held that “the plurality of inventions would have to be tested based upon the disclosures made in either the provisional or complete specification.” (para 32)

Provisions and topics

Provisions

Cases on this page

Case page

Syngenta Ltd v Controller of Patents and Designs (2023)

High Court of Delhi·13 October 2023

See also

Doctrine page

Claims: Function and Form

Do the claims alone define the monopoly of a patent, or does the description count?

Doctrine page

Divisional Applications

What filing date does a divisional patent application get in India?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/unity-of-invention