Revocation for non-compliance with Section 8 is discretionary, not automatic; a partial, explained omission is no unequivocal admission, so no decree revoking the patent on admission: appeal dismissed.
Summary
The respondent’s suit sought “a decree for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from infringing its essential DVD Video/DVD ROM Disc Patents, in particular Indian Patent with registered No.218255” (para 1). The defendants made “a counter claim for revocation of the suit patent under Section 64(1)(m) of the Patents Act, 1970” “for non-compliance of the provisions of Section 8”, and then “filed I.A. No.21411 of 2012 under Order XII Rule 6 of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (hereinafter referred as CPC) with a prayer to pass a decree on the basis of the alleged admissions made by the plaintiff.” (para 2) The counter-claim rested on “failure of the plaintiff to disclose to the Controller of Patents (COP) the information as required by Section 8 of the Patents Act 1970, read with Rule 12 of the Patents Rules, 2003” (para 5). After the written statement, “the Patent Attorney of the plaintiff by letter dated 14.09.2012 informed the COP” “that certain details regarding the corresponding foreign filings were not submitted during the prosecution of Patent No.218255” (para 6). “The said application was dismissed by the learned Single Judge by order dated 06.11.2013. Hence, this appeal by the defendants.” (para 2)
The Bench held that “though any violation of the requirement under Section 8 may attract Section 64(1)(m) for revocation of the patent, such revocation is not automatic.” (para 38) “the power to revoke a patent under Section 64(1) is discretionary and consequently it is necessary for the Court to consider the question as to whether the omission on the part of the plaintiff was intentional or whether it was a mere clerical and bonafide error.” (para 40) On the application, “it cannot be held that there is any unequivocal admission by the plaintiff and consequently, it is not a matter for granting a decree even before the evidence is let in by the parties as provided under Order XII Rule 6 of CPC.” (para 49) “The order under appeal does not suffer from any infirmity and, therefore, the appeal shall stand dismissed.” (para 50)
What the court decided
- Section 8 and Rule 12. “A combined reading of Section 8 of the Patents Act and Rule 12 of the Patents Rules shows that the applicant along with his application for a patent or subsequently within six months from the date of filing the application is required to file a statement furnishing the detailed particulars of the application, if any, being prosecuted by him in a foreign country for a patent in respect of the same or substantially same invention.” “It is also necessary for the applicant to file an undertaking that up to the date of grant of patent, he would keep the Controller informed in writing from time to time” “within six months from the date of such filing. Failure to disclose the abovesaid information required by Section 8 is one of the grounds for revocation of the Patent under Section 64(1)(m) of the Patents Act.” (para 19)
- What the plaintiff had filed. “The plaintiff in the case on hand has admittedly complied with the said requirement and both the statement under Section 8(1)(a) and the undertaking under Section 8(1)(b) were filed.” (para 24) “A reading of the above affidavit shows that there was no failure as such on the part of the plaintiff to comply with the undertaking furnished in terms of Section 8(1)(b) of the Act, but some of the details contained on the reverse of the first page of the list of the foreign applications filed on 31.08.2004 were omitted for the reasons explained by the Patent Attorney in his affidavit.” (paras 24, 26)
- A question for trial. “That being so, it cannot be straightaway concluded that the plaintiff had failed to comply with the mandatory provisions of Section 8(1) of the Patents Act. As rightly held by the learned Single Judge, the said question can be answered only at the conclusion of the trial.” (para 27)
- The word may in section 64(1). The Bench held that “the word” “employed in Section 64(1) indicates that the provision is directory and raises a presumption that the power of revocation of patents conferred under Section 64(1) is discretionary. Ordinarily, the word” “is not a word of compulsion. It is an enabling word and it confers capacity, power or authority and implies discretion.” (para 28)
- The literal rule. “Thus, it is clear that ordinarily it is not proper for the Court to depart from the literal rule as that would really be amending the law in the garb of interpretation which is impermissible under law. However, in case of ambiguity while determining whether a provision is mandatory or directory, in addition to the language used therein, the Court has to examine the context in which the provision is used and the purpose it seeks to achieve.” (para 36)
- Section 8 mandatory, section 64(1) discretionary. “In the present case, it is no doubt true that it is mandatory to comply with the requirements under Section 8(1) of the Patents Act and non-compliance of the same is one of the grounds for revocation of the patents under Section 64(1)(m). However, the fact that the word” “is used in Section 64(1) itself indicates the intention of the legislature that the power conferred thereunder is discretionary.” “We found that the language of Section 64(1) is plain and unambiguous and it clearly confers a discretion upon the authority/Court while exercising the power of revocation.” (para 37) “Therefore, we are of the view that though any violation of the requirement under Section 8 may attract Section 64(1)(m) for revocation of the patent, such revocation is not automatic.” (paras 37–38)
- Chemtura distinguished. Of Chemtura Corporation v Union of India (2009) the Bench held: “The question whether the power conferred under Section 64(1) of the Patents Act for revocation of the patent is discretionary or mandatory neither fell for consideration nor adjudicated by the Court in the said decision. Therefore, the learned Single Judge had rightly distinguished Chemutra Corporation Case (supra) relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellants/defendants.” (para 39)
- Inquiry into the omission. “For the aforesaid reasons, we are of the view that the power to revoke a patent under Section 64(1) is discretionary and consequently it is necessary for the Court to consider the question as to whether the omission on the part of the plaintiff was intentional or whether it was a mere clerical and bonafide error.” (para 40)
- Procedure. Judgment on admission. “Apparently, the purport of Order XII Rule 6 is to enable the party to obtain speedy justice to the extent of the relevant admission. However, as per the settled law, before a Court can act under Rule 6, admission must be clear, unambiguous, unconditional and unequivocal.” (para 43) “As could be seen from the ratio laid down in the above noticed decisions, a judgment can be passed under Order XII Rule 6 of CPC” (“Civil Procedure Code, 1908”) “even on constructive admissions made by the other party. However, it is only on unequivocal admission.” (paras 43, 47)
- No unequivocal admission. “However, it is not as if there was total failure on the part of the plaintiff to disclose the information in terms of the undertaking filed under Section 8(1)(b). The omission was only to furnish a part of the information for the reasons stated therein.” (para 48) “revocation is not automatic under Section 64(1)(m), but it is always open to the Court to examine the question whether the omission to furnish the information was deliberate or intentional. The revocation would follow only if the Court is of the view that the omission to furnish the information was deliberate.” (paras 48–49)
- Disposition. “For the aforesaid reasons, we are of the view that the learned Single Judge is fully justified in dismissing the application of the defendants under Order XII Rule 6 of CPC. The order under appeal does not suffer from any infirmity and, therefore, the appeal shall stand dismissed.” (para 50)
Subsequent treatment
- Followed — In Merck Sharp and Dohme v Glenmark Pharmaceuticals (2015) the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court recorded that this ruling “has again re-inforced the discretionary element consequent upon a patent applicant’s failure to comply with Section 8” and held the non-disclosure there “prima facie insufficient, in the opinion of this Court, for revocation under Section 64(1)(m)” (para 76).
- Followed — In Cipla v F Hoffmann-La Roche (2015) the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court relied on this judgment and held that “Section 64(1) is directory in nature and thus noncompliance of Section 8 would not automatically result in revocation of the patent” (paras 123–124).
- Distinguished — In AstraZeneca v Intas Pharmaceuticals (2020) the Delhi High Court held at the interlocutory stage that reliance on this judgment “misses a vital distinction”, since it “was rendered in the context of Order XII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908” whereas Chemtura “was foregrounded in the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2” (para 32.4).