Bombay Agarwal Co v Ramchand Diwanchand (1952)
High Court of Nagpur·13 February 1952
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Can an innocent infringer be made liable for damages under section 111?
Under section 111(1) no damages or account of profits lies against a defendant who proves he was not aware and had no reasonable grounds for believing that the patent existed.
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
Restrictions on Relief Under Section 111, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/section-111
1A defendant will not be liable for damages or an account of profit in case of any infringement committed after a failure to pay any renewal fee within the prescribed period and before any extension of that period. The defendant has to specifically plead that the renewal fee was not paid during this period and that the alleged act was done during the said period.
2Where an amendment is allowed after the publication of the specification, a defendant will not be liable for damages or an account of profit in respect of use of the invention before the date of the decision allowing the amendment, unless the court is satisfied that the specification as originally published, was framed in good faith and with reasonable skill and knowledge.
3Under s 111(1) of the Patents Act, a defendant shall not be liable for damages in the case of innocent infringements, ie if the acts constituting infringement were done without being aware and without having reasonable ground for believing that the patent existed. Where the infringement is committed in good faith without knowledge about an existing patent, the defendant will be protected from paying damages. (See Wilderman v FW Berk & Co Ltd [1925] Ch 116, (1925) 42 RPC 79.) As the explanation to s 111(1) suggests, mere marking of the article as ‘patent’ or ‘patented’ will not convey knowledge as required under the sub-section unless the said expressions are accompanied by the patent number. The onus is on the defendant to prove that he was not aware and had no reasonable knowledge about the existence of the patent. (See Lancer Boss Ltd v Henley Forklift Co Ltd [1974] FSR 14, (1975) RPC 307.)
4In Bombay Agarwal Co v Ramchand Diwanchand (1952) the Division Bench of the Nagpur High Court held that “However, the question of notice is irrelevant and a patent may be infringed even in ignorance.” It adopted the words of Terrell: “It is equally an infringement whether the Defendant acted in ignorance of the Plaintiff’s patent or not.” (para 31)
5On section 30 of the Patents and Designs Act 1911, which preceded s 111(1), the Andhra Pradesh High Court held in Indian Hume Pipe Co v Vendra Venkanna (1961) that “A combined reading of these provisions would show that a patentee has a right of action to restrain the infringement of a patent during the continuance of the patent only, that among other things, the validity of the patent could be raised by way of defence and that when damages are claimed in respect of infringement, the action could be successfully resisted on the ground that the defendant was not aware of the patent or had no reasonable means of making himself aware of the existence of the patent.” (para 24) “Section 30 of the Act, set out supra, is clear that the defendant has to prove that on the date of the infringement, he was not aware of the existence of the patent, nor had he reasonable means of making himself aware of the existence of such patent.” (para 25) “The plea of the defendants that they were utterly ignorant of the patent and had no means of knowing the existence of such patent, in our view, has been rightly accepted. That would mean that the defendants have made good their plea with reference to section 30 of the Patents and Designs Act, 1911, which effectively precludes the claim of the plaintiff for damages.” (paras 26–27)
6In Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v Lava International (2024), where “Lava seeks to take benefit of Section 111 of the Patents Act”, the Delhi High Court held: “I do not find merit in the aforesaid submission of Lava as Ericsson had duly provided details of its patents and had informed Lava of its infringing activities on 1 st November, 2011.” Lava “was an ‘unwilling licensee’” (para 817). Although “the publication of the eight suit patents took place between 1998 and 2000”, “in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the relevant date for determining damages would be 1 st November, 2011.” (para 818)
High Court of Andhra Pradesh·13 October 1961
High Court of Delhi·28 March 2024
Can a patent that lapsed for non-payment of renewal fees be restored in India?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/section-111