Bayer Corporation v Union of India (2014)
High Court of Bombay·15 July 2014
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Does a patentee have to meet the demand for a patented medicine in full?
Under section 84(7) the demand for the patented article must be met to an adequate extent, and in respect of medicines the adequate extent test has to be 100%.
Doctrine last updated on 14 November 2026
Reasonable Requirements of the Public, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/reasonable-requirements
1Sub-section (7) of s 84 of the Patents Act mentions the situations in which the reasonable requirements of the public shall be deemed not to have been satisfied. The law attempts to include situations where anti-competitive practices can be countered by the grant of a compulsory licence. Sub-section (7) of s 84 reads thus:
(7) For the purposes of this Chapter, the reasonable requirements of the public shall be deemed not to have been satisfied-
(a) if, by reason of the refusal of the patentee to grant a licence or licences on reasonable terms,- (i) an existing trade or industry or the development thereof or the establishment of any new trade or industry in India or the trade or industry in India or the trade or industry of any person or class of persons trading or manufacturing in India is prejudiced; or (ii) the demand for the patented article has not been met to an adequate extent or on reasonable terms; or (iii) a market for export of the patented article manufactured in India is not being supplied or developed; or (iv) the establishment or development of commercial activities in India is prejudiced; or
(b) if, by reason of conditions imposed by the patentee upon the grant of licences under the patent or upon the purchase, hire or use of the patented article or process, the manufacture, use or sale of materials not protected by the patent, or the establishment or development of any trade or industry in India, is prejudiced; or
(c) if the patentee imposes a condition upon the grant of licences under the patent to provide exclusive grant back, prevention to challenges to the validity of patent or coercive package licensing, or
(d) if the patented invention is not being worked in the territory of India on a commercial scale to an adequate extent or is not being so worked to the fullest extent that is reasonably practicable, or
(e) if the working of the patented invention in the territory of India on a commercial scale is being prevented or hindered by the importation from abroad of the patented article by- (i) the patentee or persons claiming under him; or (ii) persons directly or indirectly purchasing from him; or (iii) other persons against whom the patentee is not taking or has not taken proceedings for infringement.
2A refusal implies that the applicant had made a request to the patentee and the patentee had refused to grant a licence on reasonable terms. The refusal of the patentee to grant licence under the above provision relates to licences that are different from the exclusive licences. (See Re Colbourne Engineering Co’s Application (1955) 72 RPC 169.) Section 84(7)(a) details the instances where the refusal of the patentee to grant a licence on reasonable terms shall result in the reasonable requirements of the public not being satisfied, if it leads to the following four situations.
3The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the refusal of the patentee to grant a licence prejudices:
(a) an existing trade or industry in India; or (b) the development of an existing trade or industry in India; or (c) the establishment of any new trade or industry in India; or (d) the trade or industry of any person or class of persons trading or manufacturing in India.
4The Patents Act employs the expression ‘prejudiced’ without any qualifications in s 84(7). It employs the expression ‘unfairly prejudiced’ in s 89(b). Section 89 provides that the powers of the Controller in a s 84 application shall be exercised with a view to secure some general purposes, which includes unfair prejudice that may be caused to ’the interest of any person for the time being working or developing an invention in the territory of India under the protection of a patent’. (Patents Act 1970, s 89(b).) The Patents Act also uses the expression ‘unduly prejudiced’ in the context of termination of compulsory licences. (Ibid, s 94(2).)
5For the purpose of s 84(7), any prejudice caused to the trade or industry in India will suffice. In any case, the difference between ‘prejudiced’ and ‘unfairly prejudiced’ is not significant as it could be expected of the Controller to consider the public interest whether or not he was specifically directed to do so. The Controller will be required to take into account the ability of any person to whom a licence would be granted under the order to work the invention to the public advantage. (See Re Colbourne Engineering Co’s Application (1955) 72 RPC 169, p 176.)
6The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the refusal of the patentee to grant a licence results in the demand for the patented article not being met to an adequate extent or on reasonable terms. A demand may be a demand for domestic consumption or for export. (Patents Act 1970, ss 84(7)(a)(iii) and 92A. See also Boult’s Patent (1909) 26 RPC 383, p 387 (Application for licence was refused without costs); Kent’s Patent (1909) 26 RPC 666, p 671 (application for licence was refused with costs).)
7The patentee may take a plea that there is no demand for the patented article. In United Kingdom, the absence of any demand for the patented article in that country will not be a valid excuse. (‘If he (the patentee) does in fact manufacture in foreign countries, and if there is in fact a demand for the article or process abroad, the absence of any demand here (in United Kingdom) does not seem to be a valid excuse. The patentee must, in such cases, make an effort to create a demand here, and the establishment of an industry will in itself help to create in many cases a demand for the article or process in question.’ See Boult’s Patent (1909) 26 RPC 383, p 387.) But where the technology of the invention was surpassed and it was not commercially viable to establish a manufacture of that invention in United Kingdom, the patentee’s action of charging royalties on imported French cars containing the patented mechanism will be regarded as not meeting the demand. (See Osborn’s Patent (1909) 26 RPC 819, pp 821-822. In the above case, the patentees were owners of English patent but did not manufacture the products in United Kingdom. The patentees had however sold patented articles as imported from a French company. The patentees used their rights not for the purpose of manufacture but for levying a toll on the English purchaser. The application for licence was dismissed with costs.) If, pursuant to an application made for a compulsory licence, the patentee starts manufacture in that country where it was previously meeting the demand for the patented article by importation, it will not be open for the patentee to contend that the demand for the patent article was met to an adequate extent. (‘I do not think that the manufacture which the Patentees’ Licensees have setup here, after the dates of the present application, can be said to have resulted in the working of the patented invention in this country on a commercial scale.’ See Fabricmeter Co Ltd’s Applications (1936) 53 RPC 307, p 312.)
8Under the ground that the demand for a patented article has not been fully met, it should be shown that the demand must be an actual one and not merely one which an applicant hopes or expects to create. (See Cathro’s Applications (1934) 51 RPC 75, p 82-83.) The conditions stated in s 84(7)(a)(ii) of the Patents Act require that the demand for the patented article must not have been met to an ‘adequate extent’ or on ‘reasonable terms’. The latter expression introduces the element of affordability and in determining the demand for the patented article, the price stipulated for such an article will be relevant. Thus, if the price charged for the patented article made in a country is higher than that charged for the imported article, the bona fides of the price may be looked into. The Controller can consider whether the price is a bona fide one and is not a price adapted for the very purpose of checking and diminishing the demand for the home-manufactured article. (See Kent’s Patent (1909) 26 RPC 666, p 670.)
9In Bayer v Union of India (2014) the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that “this exercise can never be carried out on a mathematical basis. It has to be on a broad basis” and that “The aspect of adequate extent would vary from article to article.” It held that “In respect of medicines the adequate extent test has to be 100% i.e. to the fullest extent. Medicine has to be made available to every patient and this cannot be deprived/scarified at the altar of rights of patent holder.” It held that “Therefore infringer’s quantity of goods cannot be taken into account only because it could stop on any day. It is only where the patent holder accepts the infringer’s participation in the market and in fact grants him defacto licence could the infringer’s supplies be taken into account”, and that “the obligation to meet the reasonable requirement of the public is of the patent holder alone either by itself or through its licensees.” (para 13)
10The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the refusal of the patentee to grant a licence results in a situation where a market for export of the patented article manufactured in India is not being supplied or developed. (Patents Act 1970, s 92A.) The Patents Act provides for the grant of a compulsory licence for supply and development of a market for export of a patented article manufactured in India. In determing whether the demand for the patented article has been met under s 84(7)(a)(ii), the condition under s 84(7)(d) that the patent is not being worked ’to the fullest extent that is reasonably practicable’ shall also be considered. The inter-relation between the two grounds was demonstrated by Graham J in Penn Engineering & Manufacturing Corporation’s Patent: ([1972] FSR 533, p 545, (1973) RPC 233.)
In my judgment, particularly at the present time, public interest does demand that exports from this country should be on as large a scale as possible. At the same time it would not be right to deprive the inventor of such reasonable remuneration as he may be able himself to get from his own exploitation of his patent. …If the patentee is already manufacturing in this country and exporting to foreign countries it might well be reasonable for him to ask that the grant of a compulsory licence should be restricted so as to prevent export by the licensee to those countries to which he (the patentee) is already exporting. If however the patentee is not manufacturing here and does not possess foreign patents in countries in which there is likely to be a market for export from this country, there seems very little, if any, reason to put restrictions on export in a compulsory licence to be granted. Any such restriction will prevent working ’to the fullest extent that is reasonably practicable’, and it is, in my judgment, incumbent upon the patentee to ask for and justify such a restriction if he wishes to get it inserted in a compulsory licence order made against him.’
11The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the refusal of the patentee to grant a licence prejudices the establishment or development of commercial activities in India. The foregoing explanation of the expression ‘prejudiced’ will be applicable to the above ground as well.
12The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the conditions imposed by the patentee upon the grant of licence under the patent or upon the purchase, hire or use of the patented article or process, prejudices:
(1) the manufacture, use or sale of materials not protected by the patent; or (2) the establishment or development of any trade or industry in India.
13The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the patentee imposes a condition upon the grant of licences under the patent for:
(a) exclusive grant back; or (b) prevention to challenges to the validity of patent; or (c) coercive package licensing.
14Coercive package licensing includes instances where the patentee may insist upon licensing a group of patents together and stipulate royalties on non-patented articles. (See Brownie Wireless Co Ltd’s Application (1929) 46 RPC 457, pp 476-77. On the facts and circumstances of the case, the court held that it was reasonable to demand royalty on non-patented articles.) In certain cases, the patentee may impose restrictive conditions for the grant of a licence in such a manner that it would defeat the very purpose of such grant. Such conditions will have the effect of not satisfying the reasonable requirements of the public.
15The reasonable requirements of the public will not be deemed to have been satisfied if the patented invention is not being worked in India on a commercial scale to an adequate extent or if it is not being so worked to the fullest extent that is reasonably practicable. The Controller may require a patentee or licensee to furnish information as to the extent to which the patented invention has been commercially worked in India. (Patents Act 1970, s 146(1).) The patentee or the licensee may furnish a statement in Form 27 with regard to the extent to which the patented invention has been worked on a commercial scale in India. (Ibid, s 146(2). Patents Rules 2003, r 131.)
16A compulsory licence will be granted if the patented invention is not worked to the fullest extent that is reasonably practicable. (See Gebhardt’s Patent (1992) RPC 1, p 7.) An applicant making an application on the above ground will have to establish the demand expected for the patented invention and the extent to which it has not been satisfied. (See Kamborian’s Patent (1961) RPC 403, p 405.) As a defence to reject the application, the patentee has to show that the invention is being presently worked in the country on the date of the application for compulsory licence. (‘It is, of course, of first class import to consider the actual position at the date of application, for, if there is no actual working at that date, it may well be that the subsequent working has been arranged solely for the purpose of defeating the application and is not really bona fide.’ See McKechnie Bros Ltd’s Application (1934) 51 RPC 461, p 467. See also Fabricmeter Co Ltd’s Application (1936) 53 RPC 307, p 312.) Reliance on the fact that the invention was once worked and then discontinued will not be a sufficient defence. (Cathro’s Application (1934) 51 RPC 75, p 79.)
Can a compulsory licence be granted in India because a patented medicine is too expensive?
Must a patent be manufactured in India to be worked in the territory of India?
Is Chapter XVI a complete code on abuse of patent rights?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/reasonable-requirements