Dr Reddy's Laboratories Limited v Controller of Patents (2022)
High Court of Delhi·10 November 2022
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Does an appeal under the Patents Act lie to the IPAB or to the High Court?
The Tribunals Reforms Act 2021 abolished the Intellectual Property Appellate Board, and jurisdiction in respect of appeals and revocation petitions has now been transferred back to High Courts.
Doctrine last updated on 14 November 2026
Abolition of the IPAB, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/ipab-abolition
1Since 2021, the Tribunals Reforms Act 2021 abolished the Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB) and restored the position as it existed before the creation of the IPAB, i.e., all appeals lie to the High Court.
2In Dr Reddy’s Laboratories v Controller of Patents (2022) the Delhi High Court recorded the impact of Tribunal Reforms Act, 2021 (TRA) and held that “Post the TRA, jurisdiction in respect of appeals and revocation petitions under the 1970 Act has now been transferred back to High Courts.” (para 3) It recorded that “The enactment of the TRA which came into effect from 4th April, 2021, resulted in the abolition of various tribunals under different statutes. One such tribunal which was abolished by the TRA was the IPAB which was dealing with disputes under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, Copyright Act, 1957 and Patents Act, 1970 and other Intellectual Property statutes. Under Section 33(3) of the TRA, the abolition of the IPAB was immediate and all pending cases before the IPAB were transferred to the High Courts before which they would have been filed had the TRA been in force on the date of filing of such appeal or application or initiation of the proceeding.” (para 56) A revocation petition filed before the IPAB “now stands transferred to the High Court of Madras” (para 106). (Tribunals Reforms Act 2021, s 33(3).)
3The Intellectual Property Appellate Board established under s 83 of the Trade Marks Act 1999 shall act as the Appellate Board for the purposes of the Patents Act. The Appellate Board shall exercise the jurisdiction, power and authority conferred on it under the Patents Act. (Patents Act 1970, s 116(1).) Before the changes brought about by the Patents (Amendment) Act 2002, an appeal from any decision, order or direction of the Controller, as mentioned in s 116(2) of the Patents Act (as it was before the amendment) would lie to the high court. This power has now been transferred to the Appellate Board. Until the provisions pertaining to the Appellate Board come into force by notification in the Official Gazette, the power to entertain appeals and applications (petitions for revocation and rectification) will remain with the high court, as it was under the Patents Act before the Patents (Amendment) Act 2002. (Patents (Amendment) Act 2005, s 1(2).) Under the earlier provision, any appeal would lie to the high court from any decision, order or direction of the Controller from the provisions mentioned in s 116(2), as it existed before the amendment. Similarly, a petition for rectification under s 71 or a petition for revocation under s 64 would lie to the high court. The procedure for such an appeal or an application (petition) to the high court shall be governed by the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 and the relevant high court rules, whichever may be applicable.
4The following discussion is confined to the procedure that may be followed before the Appellate Board once the provisions pertaining to the Appellate Board under the Patents Act are notified. Needless to say, till the Appellate Board is notified, the powers of the Appellate Board shall be discharged by the high court.
5The Appellate Board shall consist of a Chairman, Vice-Chairman and other members as the Central Government may prescribe. A Bench shall consist of one judicial member and one technical member. The composition and the working of the members shall be the same as detailed under s 84 of the Trade Marks Act 1999 except for the technical member, who shall have the following qualifications, namely: (Patents Act 1970, s 116(2).)
(a) has, at least five years, held the post of Controller under this Act or has exercised the functions of the Controller under this Act for at least five years; or (b) has, for at least ten years, functioned as a Registered Patent Agent and possesses a degree in engineering or technology or a masters degree in science from any University established under law for the time being in force or equivalent.
6The jurisdiction of the Appellate Board extends beyond mere appellate functions as its name would indicate. The Appellate Board has original jurisdiction with regard to matters mentioned in s 117D(1) of the Patents Act. The Appellate Board may also exercise appellate jurisdiction with regard to matters mentioned in s 117A(2). The original jurisdiction of the Appellate Board pertains to matters which are preferred to the Appellate Board at the first instance. No court or authority shall have jurisdiction to entertain matters over which the Appellate Board has exclusive authority. (Patents Act 1970, s 117C.) The Appellate Board may entertain, at the first instance, an application for revocation of a patent under s 64, and an application for rectification of the register under s 71.
7Under s 64(1), a petition for revocation may be preferred directly to the Appellate Board on any of the grounds mentioned therein. An aggrieved person may make an application for rectification before the Appellate Board.
8The appellate jurisdiction of the Appellate Board includes the power to entertain both original appeals as well as transferred appeals. (See Intellectual Property Appellate Board (Procedure) Rules 2003, r 2(d).)
9Section 117A deals with original appeals. It details the decisions, orders and directions passed by the Controller or the Central Government over which an appeal can be preferred to the Appellate Board. No court or authority shall have jurisdiction over matters mentioned in s 117A(2). (Patents Act 1970, s 117C.) Every appeal under s 117A shall be accompanied by a copy of the decision, order or direction appealed against along with the prescribed fees. An appeal shall be made within three months from the date of such decision, order or direction made by the Controller or the Central Government or within such time as may be allowed.
10Under s 117A(2) the following decisions, order and directions can be appealed:
(1) An order of the Controller refusing an application or requiring an amendment under s 15; (2) An order of the Controller for division of application under s 16(3); (3) A direction of the Controller with regard to dating of application under s 17; (4) An order of the Controller refusing an application under s 18(1); (5) A direction of the Controller requiring a reference to another specification under s 18(2); (6) Any direction of the Controller requiring or deleting a reference to another patent under s 19; (7) Any direction of the Controller requiring substitution of applicants under s 20; (8) An order of the Controller maintaining, amending or revoking a patent under s 25(4); (9) Any order of the Controller mentioning the inventor under s 28; (10) Any direction of the Controller to co-owners under s 51; (11) An order of the Controller granting a patent of addition under s 54; (12) An order of the Controller amending the application, specification or document under s 57; (13) An order of the Controller restoring a lapsed patent under s 61(3); (14) An order of the Controller revoking a patent pursuant to surrender under s 63(4); (15) An order of the Central Government revoking a patent under s 66; (16) An order of the Controller making entries in the register under s 69(3); (17) An order of the Controller correcting any clerical error in any patent, specification or document under s 78; (18) An order of the Controller granting a licence under s 84(4); (19) An order of the Controller revoking a patent under s 85(3); (20) An order of the Controller granting licences to customers of the applicant under s 88(1); (21) An order of the Controller cancelling or amending an existing licence under s 88(2); (22) An order of the Controller reviewing the terms and conditions of a licence under s 88(4); (Though s 88(4) mentions only about an application for the revision of the terms and conditions of an existing licence, it is implied that the Controller will have the power to grant or refuse such an application. The broad language used in s 117A, which refers to an order passed under s 88 without mentioning the sub-sections, should cover appeals from an order passed pursuant to an application filed under s 88(4).) (23) An order of the Controller granting a licence of a related patent under s 91(3); (24) An order of the Controller pursuant to notifications by the Central Government granting a licence under s 92(1)(i); and (25) An order of the Controller terminating a compulsory licence under s 94(1).
11Though s 60 is mentioned in s 117A (2), no decision, order or direction is passed pursuant to it, hence the reference to the same is inappropriate. Similarly, the references to sub-ss (1) to (5) of s 84 are misleading as an order is passed only under s 84(4) which can be the subject matter of an appeal.
12Section 117G provides that all appeals against any order or decision of the Controller and all cases of revocation of patent (other than the one raised as a counter-claim in a revocation suit) and rectification of register pending before any high court shall be transferred to the Appellate Board upon the notification by the Central Government. Upon such transfer, the Appellate Board may proceed with the matter afresh or from the stage in which it was transferred. Section 117G of the Act is similar to s 100 of the Trade Marks Act 1999. The IPAB (Procedure) Rules 2003 defines ’transferred application or appeal’ as an application or an appeal or other proceedings which has been transferred to the Appellate Board under s 100 of the Trade Marks Act 1999. The provisions of the IPAB (Procedure) Rules 2003 shall apply mutatis mutandis to the Patents Act 1970 as well.
High Court of Delhi·10 November 2022
Can an order of the Patent Controller be appealed to the High Court?
Can a Patent Office order be challenged in a writ petition before a High Court?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/ipab-abolition