Case page

Hind Mosaic and Cement Works v Shree Sahjanand Trading Corporation (2008)

High Court of Gujarat·M.S. Shah & K.A. Puj JJ·Division Bench·Decided 25 January 2008·2008 (37) PTC 128 (Guj); MIPR 2008 (1) 402

Good law Appeal allowed: the Single Judge's order of 21 August 2007 refusing interim relief quashed and the trial judge's ad-interim relief restored till the final disposal of Civil Suit No. 1 of 2007, on the appellants' undertaking to answer in damages, and the request for a stay of the order rejected. The Delhi High Court held in 2015 that the judgment does not expressly address the test of infringement of a product patent. No further appeal traced as of 27 October 2026. Interlocutory

The Single Judge's findings on Section 3(f), suppression and the Austrian search report being untenable, the refusal of an interim injunction was set aside and ad-interim relief restored.

Cite this page

Hind Mosaic and Cement Works v Shree Sahjanand Trading Corporation, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/hind-mosaic

Judgment PDF

Summary

“The appellants/original plaintiffs have filed this Appeal against the order and judgment dated 21.8.2007 of the learned Single Judge of this Court passed in Injunction Application in Civil Suit No. 1 of 2007 in its original jurisdiction, rejecting the Interim Application for injunction and consequently vacating the temporary injunction granted by the learned City Civil Judge, Ahmedabad in Regular Civil Suit prior to its transfer to this Court.” (p 1) The appellant had “invented the invention viz.” ‘Polyvinyl Chloride threaded pipe joint system with coupler and wire locking device comprising two pipe joining components, two sealing rings, including a wire lock’ (p 1), and on learning that “the identical product described as ‘first kind of PVC Wire Lock System in the world’ is being produced and marketed by respondent No. 2” the appellants filed a suit and “filed application for interim injunction under the provisions of Order 39 Rule 1 and 2” (p 1). “On service of summons, the respondents appeared and filed reply as well as counter claim for revocation of patent. As per the provisions contained under Section 104 of the Patent Act, the entire suit proceedings were, therefore, transferred to this Court” (p 2), and the Single Judge then held “that the invention for which the patent is granted, would fall in the category of Section 3(f) being exception to Section 2(j) and 2(ja) of the Act and, therefore, the invention is not patentable” (p 13).

The Bench held that “the order and judgment of the learned Single Judge refusing the interim relief is not sustainable either on facts as well as on law and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside” (p 12), that “All these findings and observations made by the Learned Single Judge are not tenable” (p 13), that “the Learned Single Judge has not considered the very vital aspect in its true perspective that the patent was granted under Section 48 of the Patent Act whereby the rights of the appellant patentee were statutorily recognized” (p 13), and that “the Learned Single Judge has not considered the expert’s report and affidavits in their true perspectives” (p 13). After setting out the principles of American Cyanamid Co. v. Ethicon Ltd. (1975) 1 All ER 504, it held: “Accordingly, the order passed by the Learned Single Judge is quashed and set aside and the order of the learned Trial Judge granting ad-interim relief is hereby restored and the said interim relief shall continue till the final disposal of the suit.” (p 14)

What the court decided

  1. The order under appeal. “After having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties and after having gone through the pleadings of the parties as well as the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge refusing to grant interim relief and after having considered various authorities cited before the Court as well as the statutory provisions relevant to the issues involved in this appeal, we are of the view that the order and judgment of the learned Single Judge refusing the interim relief is not sustainable either on facts as well as on law and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside” (p 12)
  2. The findings below. Of the Single Judge’s findings that there was no “synergistic effect”, that the invention “would fall in the category of Section 3(f) being exception to Section 2(j) and 2(ja) of the Act”, that “the appellants have misled the Court by giving only one sided version and suppressed the other relevant circumstances of PCT Report of Austrian, Vienna”, that “there was no prima facie case at all on merit for sustaining the patent, but on the contrary, the prima facie case is for revocation of the patent”, and that “the conduct of the appellants disentitles them to claim equitable relief”, the Bench held: “All these findings and observations made by the Learned Single Judge are not tenable in view of the discussion made above in light of the facts found and evidence produced before the Court.” (p 13)
  3. The Austrian search report. “International Search Report of Austrian Patent Office is prepared without the aid of 16 drawings. The position of grooves, the thread and the sealings inside the coupling were not known. The appellants were not aware about this report as no specific search was made nor drawings were transmitted to Austria. Even the report itself made it clear that there was no legal status for the purpose of the PTC procedure.” (p 13)
  4. The grant under Section 48. “As a matter of fact, the Learned Single Judge has not considered the very vital aspect in its true perspective that the patent was granted under Section 48 of the Patent Act whereby the rights of the appellant patentee were statutorily recognized.” (p 13)
  5. The three ingredients. “The law relating to grant of interim relief is well established by now and all the three ingredients, namely, prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss are present in this case and, therefore, initially the Trial Court has rightly granted interim relief and only when the respondents have filed an application for revocation of patent, the case was transferred to this Court and thereafter, the Learned Single Judge has vacated this interim relief.” (p 13)
  6. The expert’s report. “By vacating this interim relief, the Learned Single Judge has not considered the expert’s report and affidavits in their true perspectives.” (p 13)
  7. The principles applied. Of American Cyanamid Co. v. Ethicon Ltd. (1975) 1 All ER 504 the Bench recorded that “the question of grant of injunction in patent cases has been considered minutely and at length” and that “The principles enunciated therein are as under”: “There is no rule that a plaintiff must make out a prima facie case.”; “It is no part of the Court’s function at this stage of the litigation to try to resolve conflicts of evidence on affidavit as to facts on which the claims of either party may ultimately depend nor to decide difficult questions of law which call for detailed agreement and mature considerations.”; “If damages in the measure recoverable at common law would be an adequate remedy and the defendant would be in a financial position to pay them, no interlocutory injunction should normally be granted, however, strong the plaintiffs claim appeared to be at that stage.”; “It is where there is doubt as to the adequacy of the respective remedies in damages available to either party or to both, that the question of balance of convenience arises.”; “Where other factors appear to be evenly balanced it is a counsel of prudence to take such measures as are calculated to preserve the status quo.”; and “If the extent of the uncompensatable disadvantage to each party would not differ widely, it may not be improper to take into account in tipping the balance the relative strength of each party’s case as revealed by this affidavit evidence adduced on the hearing of the application.” (p 14)
  8. Interim relief restored. “Applying the above principles to the facts of the present case, we hold that the views expressed by the Learned Single Judge do not prima facie hold the field and find that this is a fit case where interim relief is required to be granted. Accordingly, the order passed by the Learned Single Judge is quashed and set aside and the order of the learned Trial Judge granting ad-interim relief is hereby restored and the said interim relief shall continue till the final disposal of the suit.” (p 14)
  9. The cross-undertaking. “It is however made clear that ultimately if the appellants fail in succeeding in the suit, the respondents are entitled to the damages to the extent of loss suffered by them for discontinuing their business because of grant of this interim relief. The quantum of loss shall be decided, if need so arises, by the” “Court while disposing of the suit on merits. The appellants shall file an undertaking before the Court to this effect.” (p 15)
  10. Procedure. The stay refused. On the respondent’s prayer “for stay of the order”, to which the appellants “objected”, the Bench held: “Considering the the facts and circumstances of the case, the request made by Mr.Pranav Trivedi for stay of the order is rejected.” (p 15)

Subsequent treatment

Explained — In Cipla v F Hoffmann-La Roche (2015) the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court, on the correct test of infringement of a product patent, said that “While this issue was indeed framed by the Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court in” “the decision reported as 2008 (37) PTC 128(Guj)”, “the decision does not expressly address this question.” (para 108)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases this judgment relies on

Cited in

Case page · Page updated 18 November 2026

www.aop.onl/hind-mosaic