The Grounds of Revocation: A Map of Section 64
Which grounds can be used to revoke an Indian patent?
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Are the grounds of pre-grant and post-grant opposition under section 25 the same?
The grounds of pre-grant and post-grant opposition are substantially the same, the only difference being the stages at which these grounds can be introduced, under sections 25(1) and 25(2).
Doctrine last updated on 12 November 2026
The Grounds of Opposition: A Map of Section 25, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/grounds-of-opposition
1The Patents Act provides for opposition before the grant of a patent (pre-grant opposition) as well as for opposition after the grant (post-grant opposition).The grounds of opposition for pre-grant and post-grant opposition are substantially the same. The only difference is with regard to the stages at which these grounds can be introduced in an opposition. By definition, pre-grant opposition happens before the grant of the patent, ie, at the application stage. Thus, the 11 grounds on which an application can be opposed are mentioned in s 25(1) as the ones that can be exercised before the grant. The same grounds find mention is s 25(2) as the ones that can be exercised after the grant of the patent.
2Chapter V of the Patents Act, which comprises ss 25 to 28, deals with opposition. The corresponding rules are contained in rr 55 to 70. Section 25(1) deals with the grounds of pre-grant opposition and s 25(2) details the grounds of post-grant opposition. The grounds of post-grant opposition were introduced by the Patents (Amendment) Act 2005. The grounds of opposition in s 25(1), as they were before the Patents (Amendment) Act 2005, are still applicable to opposition proceedings instituted before the said amendment.
3The grounds of opposition contained in s 25 of the Patents Act were inspired by the provisions of s 14(1) of the UK Patents Act 1949. The striking similarity of s 14 of the UK Patents Act 1949 with the grounds of opposition under s 25 of the Patents Act makes it an ideal subject for a comparative analysis. Thus, the decisions rendered under s 14 of the UK Patents Act 1949 are discussed here in detail under the relevant headings. The mechanism of opposition no longer exists in the UK Patents Act 1977, as the EPC provides for a centralised system of opposition in arts 99 to 105 of the EPC. Article 100 of the EPC which details the grounds of opposition reads:
Article 100
Grounds for opposition
Opposition may only be filed on the grounds that–
(a) the subject-matter of the European patent is not patentable within the terms of Articles 52 to 57; (b) the European patent does not disclose the invention in a manner sufficiently clear and complete for it to be carried out by a person skilled in the art; (c) the subject-matter of the European patent extends beyond the content of the application as filed, or, if the patent was granted on a divisional application or on a new application filed in accordance with Article 61, beyond the content of the earlier application as filed.
4An application or a patent may be opposed on the ground that what is claimed was in fact already claimed in a specification published in India with an earlier priority date. In other words, an opposition may be made where the invention in so far as claimed in any claim of the complete specification is claimed in a claim of a complete specification published on or after the priority date of the applicant’s claim and filed in pursuance of an application for a patent in India, being a claim of which the priority date is earlier than that of the applicant’s claim. The above grounds are similar to the ground of revocation in s 64(1)(a).
5The above grounds deal with anticipation by an application. These grounds cover both an earlier claim which is a part of a granted patent and a claim which forms part of a pending application. However, the grant of a patent will not be refused on this ground if no patent came to be granted with respect to the prior claim. An application may be opposed on this ground by an earlier patentee who claims earlier priority. In some cases, suitable amendments can take care of the objections raised under this ground. The applicant may also remedy the situation by inserting a reference to the prior claim.
6Sections 25(1)(c) and 25(2)(c) of the Patents Act provide for one of the four grounds on which an application or a patent can be opposed on the ground of lack of novelty. The other three grounds are contained in ss 25(1)(b) and 25(2)(b), 25(1)(d) and 25(2)(d), and 25(1)(k) and 25(2)(k).
7The above sections require that the specification be published in India. Thus, the publication of a convention application which is not filed in India shall not be used to oppose an application or patent on the above grounds.
8In an opposition proceeding, the opponents would be entitled to rely on any claim of the specification cited by them, if they could establish publication of the specification at the time of hearing of the opposition. It is not necessary that such publication is mentioned in the notice of opposition. (See California Research Corpn’s Application (1952) 69 RPC 193, p 195.)
9If an application is objected to on the ground of prior claiming and the prior specification cited is not accepted within the statutory period and becomes void, the objection on the ground of prior claiming cannot be continued. The practice in the United Kingdom is to permit opposition on the ground of prior claiming in a complete specification which had not been accepted and published at the date of the notice of opposition if such application was in the name of the opponent. (See UK Patents Act 1949, s 14(1)(c).)
10Prior claiming as an issue may arise in a variety of proceedings. (See Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd’s Application (1959) RPC 103.) It may be raised by the Patent Office at the time of examination under s 13 or by the Controller under s 18 or by the opponent pursuant to ss 25(1)(c) and 25(2)(c) or by any person interested in revocation proceedings before the High Court or in an infringement suit before the high court under s 64. If in a proceeding before the Controller, the Controller is satisfied that prior claiming is established, he may direct the applicant to amend the specification to his satisfaction. He may also require the insertion of a reference to the earlier patent unless the applicant submits an appropriate amendment. If a reference is directed by the Controller, the issue whether the claim is fairly based on the matter disclosed in the specification under s 10(5) must also be determined. A reference may be inserted in any appropriate form in the language of the patent claim. (See also General Electric Co’s Patent (Revocation) (1959) RPC 109; Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd’s Application (1959) RPC 115.)
11The course to be adopted in cases of prior claiming is detailed in Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd’s Application by Justice Lloyd-Jacob in the following passage: ((1959) RPC 103, p 108.)
What then should be the proper course to follow in prior claiming cases brought under the opposition section of the present Act? Refusal as an ultimate sanction available to the Comptroller-General in respect of any patent application is clear, but recourse to it, as has been stated over and over again, should only be made in cases where there is no room for doubt of potential validity. In instances where the validity of the prior grant is either established, conceded or not in substance challenged, the protection afforded to the later applicant by section 32 (of the UK Patents Act 1949) if he should secure a grant becomes valueless, and refusal will rob him of nothing. Where validity of the cited prior grant is shown to be open to reasonable attack the applicant should be given an opportunity to amend. If this is accepted and an amended specification submitted, the Comptroller must necessarily bring to its consideration the power of refusal if it fails to satisfy him. If, however, the amendment submitted or offered to be adopted takes the form of a statutory reference, and the reason for making it made apparent on the file, I take the view that the Comptroller-General should accept it. This will make it sufficiently clear that the applicant has chosen not more specifically to differentiate his alleged invention from the cited document, with the consequence that he may well forfeit any likelihood thereafter of the exercise of the discretionary power to permit further amendment in that connection.
12If the applicant offers to insert a reference by amendment of the specification, the Controller shall accept a reference by number to the prior claim to be inserted by an amendment. If the invention applied for cannot be performed without substantial risk of infringement of a claim in another patent, the Controller may direct the insertion of a reference to the other patent in the applicant’s complete specification.
13An application or a patent may be opposed on the ground that the subject matter of any claim of a complete specification is not an invention within the meaning of the Act or is not patentable under the Patents Act. This is a general ground which is broad enough to include all the provisions of the Patents Act by which an invention and its patentability are determined. A granted patent may be revoked on a similar ground under s 64(1)(d).
14An application or a patent may be opposed on the ground that the complete specification does not sufficiently and clearly describe the invention or the method by which it is to be performed. A patent that is granted may also be revoked on a similar ground under s 64(1)(h). But certain differences do exist between the two provisions. The word ‘clearly’, which appears in ss 25(1)(g) and 25(2)(g) is replaced by the expression ‘fairly’ in s 64(1)(h). Further, the expression ‘sufficiently and fairly describe’ is elaborated in s 64(1)(h).
15Sufficiency of description may be enquired into at any stage of the life of a patent. It may be questioned at the application stage under s 12(1)(a) as s 10(4) requires a complete specification to ‘fully and particularly describe the invention’. It may be called to question in an opposition proceeding, before or after the grant, under ss 25(1)(g) and 25(2)(g) on the ground that the complete specification does not ‘sufficiently and clearly describe the invention’. It may also be brought in issue in a revocation proceeding under s 64(1)(h) before the high court on the ground that the complete specification does not ‘sufficiently and fairly describe the invention’.
16The wordings in the above three provisions, though dealing with the issue of description, do vary in their ambit and scope. The expressions ‘fully and particularly’, ‘sufficiently and clearly’ and ‘sufficiently and fairly’ have been interpreted by the courts. With regard to the relevant provisions of the above sub-sections, the expression ’not sufficiently and clearly’ must be decided on the facts and circumstances of each case. (See General Tire & Rubber Co v Firestone Tyre and Rubber Co Ltd (1971) RPC 173, p 248, [1970] FSR 268.)
17The Controller will have to determine whether or not the description which has been given by the applicant/patentee will be sufficient to enable a person who is reasonably skilled in the particular field to make an embodiment of the invention which will have the features that would make it fall within the objects of the invention. In considering the question of insufficiency, factors such as—that the scope of the monopoly claimed is unclear; that there are inconsistencies between the description and claims; that the specification provides no explanation of the operation of the parts concerned or provides a wrong explanation of the parts concerned—will not be relevant. (See Dual Manufacturing & Engineering Inc’s Patent (1977) RPC 189.) An application will not be allowed to proceed to grant, in a case where the claims are inconsistent with the description of the invention, without a proper amendment.
18An invention may be opposed on the ground that the complete specification does not disclose or wrongly mentions the source or geographical origin of biological material used for the invention. Where the biological material is not made available to the public, it may be deposited to an international depository authority under the Budapest Treaty as contemplated in s 10(4) of the Patents Act. The above ground of opposition is similar to the ground of revocation in s 64(1)(p).
19An invention claimed in any claim of the complete specification may be opposed on the ground that it was anticipated with regard to the knowledge available within any local or indigenous community in India or elsewhere. This ground overlaps with ss 25(1)(d) and 25(2)(d), which deals with anticipation by what is ‘publicly known’ in India. But the scope of challenge in the above ground is larger as it includes what is known in ‘India or elsewhere’. The existence of such knowledge may be proved by oral or documentary evidence. Though the above sections allow for oral evidence of such knowledge, it will be difficult to prove anticipation by oral evidence especially in pre-grant opposition where the procedure is summary in nature. An invention which is a part of ’traditional knowledge’ cannot be regarded as a patentable invention under s 3(p) of the Patents Act. The above ground of opposition is similar to the ground of revocation in s 64(1)(q).
20Sections 25(1)(k) and 25(2)(k) of the Patents Act provide for one of the four grounds on which an application or a patent can be opposed on the ground of lack of novelty. The other three grounds are contained in ss 25(1)(b) and 25(2)(b), 25(1)(c) and 25(2)(c), and 25(1)(d) and 25(2)(d).
Which grounds can be used to revoke an Indian patent?
How does pre-grant opposition to a patent application work in India?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/grounds-of-opposition