A refusal for obviousness of claims the hearing notice did not carry forward breached Section 14 and natural justice: refusal set aside, application restored for fresh consideration.
Summary
“The present appeal under Section 117A of the Patents Act, 1970” assails an order “passed by the respondent, the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs”, by which “Indian Patent Application No. 202017005875” was “refused under Section 15 of the Act on the ground that claim nos. 1 to 17 lack inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) of the Act” (para 1). “The principal ground urged on behalf of the appellant is that the impugned order has been passed de hors the principles of natural justice.” (para 2) The FER (“First Examination Report”) had raised obviousness of “claim nos. 1 to 18” over “documents D1 and D2” (para 4), but “the objection under Section 2(1)(ja), as carried into the hearing notice, was confined to claim no. 18 alone” (para 7); “Claim no. 18 was given up, and the subject application proceeded on the basis of claim nos. 1 to 17.” (para 8)
The Court framed the question as “whether, given the manner in which the objection was framed in the hearing notice, the appellant had a fair and adequate opportunity to meet the ground on which the subject application was ultimately refused” (para 15). It held that “if the Controller proposes to refuse the application on a ground, that ground must first be put to the applicant” (para 20), and that here “The refusal, therefore, rests entirely on a ground which was not carried into the hearing notice.” (para 30) “Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order dated 23.01.2026 is set aside, and the subject application, i.e., Indian Patent Application No. 202017005875, is revived and restored to the file of the respondent for fresh consideration” (para 34).
What the court decided
- The question on appeal. “The Court is not called upon, in the present appeal, to decide whether claim nos. 1 to 17 of the subject application involve an inventive step. The question is whether, given the manner in which the objection was framed in the hearing notice, the appellant had a fair and adequate opportunity to meet the ground on which the subject application was ultimately refused.” (para 15)
- Sections 14, 15 and 80. “A conjoint reading of these provisions shows that the power of refusal under Section 15 is wide, but it is not free standing. It is exercised at the end of a process which Section 14 sets up.” “The satisfaction contemplated by Section 15 must, therefore, be formed on objections which have been communicated to the applicant and on which the applicant has had a fair chance to be heard. Section 80 points the same way, since it requires a hearing before the Controller exercises any discretion adversely to an applicant.” (para 19)
- Breadth of the refusal power. “The Controller is not bound to grant a patent merely because a particular objection does not find mention in the hearing notice. However, if the Controller proposes to refuse the application on a ground, that ground must first be put to the applicant. The breadth of the power under Section 15 does not dispense with the requirement of notice under Section 14.” (para 20)
- The source of the duty. “The requirements of Sections 14 and 80 are a statutory expression of the rule of audi alteram partem.” (para 21) “The Controller, while deciding whether an application for a patent should be granted or refused, discharges a quasi-judicial function, and the refusal of a patent application carries serious civil consequences for the applicant.” (paras 21, 24)
- The settled rule on hearing notices. “In the specific context of patent examination, this Court has consistently held that the hearing notice must set out every objection on which the Controller proposes to rely, and that a refusal founded on a ground not put to the applicant before the hearing cannot be sustained.” (para 25)
- The function of the hearing notice. “The FER” (“First Examination Report”) “opens the examination, and the applicant” “reply answers it. The hearing notice under Section 14 is the Controller” “statement of what, after considering the reply, still stands against the application. It narrows the dispute to the objections that remain. An applicant is entitled to take the hearing notice at face value and to prepare for the hearing on the objections listed in it.” (para 28)
- Reviving an objection not carried forward. “If the Controller intends to revive an objection which the hearing notice does not carry forward, or to raise a fresh one, requires that the applicant be told so, and be given a real opportunity to answer it, before an adverse order is passed.” (para 28)
- The hearing notice in this case. “The hearing notice did not inform the appellant that the respondent continued to regard claim nos. 1 to 17 as obvious over D1 and D2. The appellant responded to the hearing notice by giving up claim no. 18. In these circumstances, the appellant could reasonably understand that its reply to the FER had answered the objection of obviousness qua claim nos. 1 to 17.” (para 29) “Once claim no. 18 was given up, the only inventive step objection in the hearing notice had nothing left to operate upon. The refusal, therefore, rests entirely on a ground which was not carried into the hearing notice.” (paras 29–30)
- Written submissions are not notice. “Even if it is assumed that the appellant” “written submissions defended its claims generally, that cannot take the place of notice. An applicant who defends its claims in general terms, without knowing what objection it has to meet, is not in the same position as one who answers a specific objection.” (para 31)
- Prejudice. “The prejudice caused in the present case is also apparent from the impugned order itself. The appellant” “wear test data was found insufficient for want of an unexpected technical effect. That deficiency was never put to the appellant.” (para 32)
- Disposition. “The Court is, therefore, satisfied that the procedure followed by the respondent does not meet the requirements of Section 14 of the Act and the principles of natural justice. On that ground alone, the impugned order deserves to be set aside.” (para 33) The application was “revived and restored to the file of the respondent for fresh consideration” (para 34); “All rights and contentions of the parties are left open.” (para 35) “Observations made hereinabove are confined to the question of compliance with the principles of natural justice, and shall not influence the respondent while deciding the subject application on merits.” (paras 33–36)
Subsequent treatment
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 17 October 2026.