Geobrugg AG v Techfab (India) Industries Limited (2026)
High Court of Himachal Pradesh·Sandeep Sharma J·Single Judge·Decided 6 May 2026·2026:HHC:15075
A patent plaint was not rejected for non-joinder of the purchaser or want of pre-institution mediation, and acceptance of the goods in Kullu gave jurisdiction: application dismissed.
Geobrugg AG v Techfab (India) Industries Limited, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/geobrugg
Summary
The defendant applied “for rejection of plaint on the ground that same is vexatious, illusory, meritless, not disclosing any cause of action.” (para 1) The plaintiff “is owner of Indian Patent Nos. 448244 and 454374” and “The suit patents are related to high-tensile steel wire netting/ mesh used for protection against rockfall, landslides, debris flows, avalanches etc..” (para 21) “Somewhere in May 2024, plaintiff became aware that the defendant is selling wire mesh which is similar to plaintiff’s TECCO wire mesh” and “its team obtained sample of wire mesh being sold by the defendant” “to a third party i.e. Urbtech in Kullu, Himachal Pradesh.” (para 28) The defendant argued that Urbtech “is a necessary party”, that “the plaint is barred by law, since no pre-institution mediation has been exhausted”, and that “this Court does not have territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present suit.” (paras 31, 35, 38)
The Court held “that non-joinder of parties cannot be a ground for rejection of plaint.” (para 32) “Though, S.12A of the Act provides pre-institution mediation but same is not required if the suit contemplates an urgent relief.” (para 36) It held that “performance of contract was complete after acceptance of impugned product by buyer in Kullu and not in Uttarakhand” and that “this Court has territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the present suit.” (para 44) “In view of the detailed discussion made supra and various judgments passed on the subject by Hon’ble Apex Court and other High Courts, this court finds no merit in the present application and the same is accordingly dismissed.” (para 59)
What the court decided
- The Order VII rule 11 test. Following Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanushali (Gajra), the Court held that “at the time of considering application under Order VII, rule 11 CPC, only contents of plaint as well as documents relied upon can be taken into consideration but certainly, in no eventuality, averments contained in the written statement or documents relied upon by the defendant can be taken into consideration. The test is as to whether if the averments made in the plaint are taken to be correct in their entirety, a decree would be passed.” (paras 16, 20)
- Non-joinder of the purchaser. “This court is persuaded to agree” with the plaintiff “that non-joinder of parties cannot be a ground for rejection of plaint. Moreover, having carefully perused provisions of Order I, rule 9 and Order I, rule 13 CPC, it becomes clear that no suit shall be defeated by reason of misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, and the court may deal with the matter in controversy regarding the rights and interests of the parties actually before it.” (para 32) “Moreover, by placing on record invoice of impugned product, plaintiff has attempted to prove that Urbtech has bought impugned product from defendant, hence, same is not necessary party rather defendant is the only necessary party, which is manufacturing, marketing and selling the impugned product throughout India.” (para 33) The Court relied on Prem Lala Nahata & Anr v. Chandi Prasad Sikaria, “wherein it was held that Court cannot reject plaint on ground of non-joinder of parties.” (paras 32–34)
- Pre-institution mediation. “Though, S.12A of the Act provides pre-institution mediation but same is not required if the suit contemplates an urgent relief. Since, in the case at hand, an urgent relief has been contemplated, as infringement of plaintiff’s patent right is continuous, plaintiff is seeking an interim injunction.” (para 36) The Court relied on Novenco Building and Industry A/S v. Xero Energy Engineering Solutions Private Ltd. & Anr., in which the Supreme Court held that “Mere delay in institution of a suit by itself, does not negate urgency when the infringement is continuing.” (paras 36–37)
- Place of the sale. “Admittedly, in the case at hand, buyer had not examined impugned product before delivery of goods and such fact is evident from invoice itself” (para 44). “Hence, this court is persuaded to agree with Mr. Neeraj Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the plaintiff that performance of contract was complete after acceptance of impugned product by buyer in Kullu and not in Uttarakhand, as alleged by the defendant, hence, it can be said that cause of action arose in Himachal Pradesh and this Court has territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the present suit.” (para 44) Relying on Sorabji Hormusha Joshi and Co. v. V.M. Ismail (para 45), the Court held that “S.41 of said Act was not argued or considered” in the defendant’s authorities, that it “is applicable in the case at hand” and that the “Presumption under S.39 would not apply.” (paras 44–45, 48)
- Sale through an interactive website. Following Shree Girirajji and Co. v. Gagan Pagrani, which “held that Indiamart Website is an interactive site” (paras 50–51), and Kohinoor Seed Fields India Pvt. Ltd. v Veda Seed Sciences Pvt. Ltd. (para 55), the Court held that “access to an interactive website is sufficient to mean ‘carrying on business’ within the jurisdiction of this Court.” (para 54) “This Court finds that defendant’s name is clearly listed as seller of impugned product on Indiamart Website. Moreover, defendant has not denied plaintiff’s assertion that defendant is selling impugned product on Indiamart” (paras 50–51, 54–56)
- The trap sale. “This Court is not persuaded to agree with learned counsel for the defendant for the reason that sale of impugned product has been made through ordinary course of trade to a legitimate company, carrying on business i.e. Urbtech Engineering Construction Private Limited and not to an individual engaged by the plaintiff. Moreover, sale was not for a small sample but for 525 square metres of impugned product, worth Rs.4.89 Lakh.” (para 57)
- Disposition. “This court finds no merit in the present application and the same is accordingly dismissed.” (para 59) The suit was to “Be listed on 17.6.2026, for arguments on OMP No. 1079 of 2024.” (paras 59–60)
Subsequent treatment
- Appealed — On 1 September 2026 the Supreme Court (K.V. Viswanathan and Arun Palli JJ) issued notice on the defendant’s special leave petition, Techfab India Industries Limited v Geobrugg AG, SLP(C) 29151/2026, returnable on 2 November 2026, and, as reported, stayed further proceedings in the suit before the High Court.
Provisions and topics
Cited in
Case page · Page updated 14 November 2026
www.aop.onl/geobrugg