Case page

Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) v Mercury Electronics (2015)

High Court of Delhi·Najmi Waziri J·Single Judge·Decided 9 July 2015

Distinguished Objection to the onus on the issue of invalidity rejected: issue No. 7 stands as framed, with the onus on the defendants. Approved by the Division Bench in Intex v Ericsson (2023); distinguished in AstraZeneca v Intas (2020). Interlocutory

Defendants who plead invalidity of the suit patents in their counter claim bear the burden of proving it; their objection to the onus on that issue was rejected.

Cite this page

Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) v Mercury Electronics, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/ericsson-mercury

Judgment PDF

Summary

“On 07.07.2015, after considering the pleadings and upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties, issues were framed. However, the learned counsel for the defendants had objected to onus of proof qua issue No. 7 being placed on the defendants. The issue relates to the plea of invalidity set by the defendants apropos suit patents bearing registration Nos. IN203034, IN203036, IN213723, IN229632, IN240471, IN241747.” (para 1) The defendants’ counsel insisted “that onus to prove the aforesaid issue must be on the plaintiff since there can be no presumption of validity of a patent which is evident from a combined reading of Sections 13(4), 64 and 107 of the Patents Act, 1970.” (para 2)

The Court held that “the defendants in their counter claim have sought to challenge the suit patents under various grounds provided under Section 64 of the Patents Act”, so that “the burden to prove invalidity of the suit patents would squarely fall upon the defendants.” (para 8) “Assuming no evidence is led apropos the said contention, the defendants would lose.” It added that “as per Section 114 of the Evidence Act, there is a presumption of validity of the suit patents which happened in the common course of public business, i.e., grant of patent under the provisions of the Patents Act.” (para 9) The defendants’ “Reliance on Bishwanath (supra) and Ten XC Wireless (supra)” was “misplaced” (para 10). “In view of the above, issue No. 7 as framed on 07.07.2015 stands and the onus to prove the same would be on the defendants.” (para 11)

What the court decided

  1. Burden under the Evidence Act. “The principle governing framing of issues is that a material proposition of fact or law is affirmed by one party and denied by the other. Similarly, Chapter VII of the Evidence Act stipulates in clear terms, as regards the existence of burden on the parties to prove the concerned issues. Under Section 101, the burden is placed upon the person who wants his right or liability to be declared by the Court. According to Section 102, the burden is on the person, who would fail if no evidence is adduced. The next provision, Section 103 is a little specific insofar as it mandates that it is for the person who wishes the Court to believe in the existence of a particular fact to prove the same.” (para 7)
  2. The counter claim for invalidity. “From the pleadings, it is evident that the suit is on the basis of registered patents. However, the defendants in their counter claim have sought to challenge the suit patents under various grounds provided under Section 64 of the Patents Act. If the present case is examined keeping the mind the above provisions under the Evidence Act and the principles governing framing of issues, the burden to prove invalidity of the suit patents would squarely fall upon the defendants.” (para 8)
  3. Invalidity as the defendants’ assertion. “The Court is of the view that the defendants would have to discharge the burden of proving invalidity of the suit patents since it is their assertion. Assuming no evidence is led apropos the said contention, the defendants would lose. Moreover, the plea of invalidity of the suit patents is no presumption which in turn would place the burden upon the plaintiff.” (para 9)
  4. Presumption under section 114. “On the contrary, as per Section 114 of the Evidence Act, there is a presumption of validity of the suit patents which happened in the common course of public business, i.e., grant of patent under the provisions of the Patents Act.” (para 9)
  5. Bishwanath and section 13(4). “Reliance on Bishwanath (supra) and Ten XC Wireless (supra) by the learned counsel for the defendants is also misplaced. In fact, Bishwanath was premised on Section 13(4) of the Patents Act, according to which there is no presumption of validity of a patent only to the extent that no liability shall be incurred by the Central Government or any other officer thereof in connection with the grant of patent.” (para 10)
  6. Interim injunction and onus of proof. The defendants had relied on “a judgment of this Court in Ten XC Wireless Inc. & Anr. v. Mobi Antenna Technologies (Shenzhen) Co. Ltd., (2012) 187 DLT 632” (para 3); the Court held: “In Ten XC Wireless, no presumption was drawn in favour of the patent only for the purposes of an interim injunction and not for onus of proof.” (paras 3, 10)
  7. Disposition. “In view of the above, issue No. 7 as framed on 07.07.2015 stands and the onus to prove the same would be on the defendants.” (para 11)

Subsequent treatment

Followed by the Division Bench in Intex Technologies (India) v Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) (2023), which held the submission that the onus to prove the validity of the suit patents is on the plaintiff “untenable in law”, since “a learned Single Judge of this Court in TLM Ericsson (Publ) v. Mercury Electronics & Anr.” had “rightly held” so (para 132).

Distinguished in AstraZeneca v Intas Pharmaceuticals (2020), where the reliance on it was held “misplaced as that case concerned decision on the issue as to which of the contesting parties should be burdened with proving a particular issue” (para 19.4).

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases this judgment relies on

Cited in

Case page · Page updated 13 November 2026

www.aop.onl/ericsson-mercury