Telemecanique & Controls (I) Ltd v Schneider Electric Industries SA (2001)
High Court of Delhi
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
High Court of Delhi·Manmohan Singh J·Single Judge·Decided 10 June 2016
A standard-essential-patent holder won an interim injunction against an unwilling licensee: infringement was established, no credible challenge raised, and an injunction must follow.
Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v Lava International Ltd, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/ericsson-lava-2016
“The plaintiff has filed the present suit for permanent injunction against the defendant” on patents claimed to be standard essential for 2G and 3G telecommunications technology (paras 2, 72); the defendant “challenged the validity as well as essentiality of the suit patents” (para 10). On the negotiations, “All other similarly placed parties viz., Micromax, Gionee, Xiaomi, iBall, etc., are all paying royalties to Plaintiff or depositing amounts in Court and Defendant is getting an unfair advantage in the market” (para 71).
The Court found “prima facie that the defendant is an unwilling licensee, in view of the lack of bonafide displayed in its conduct during the negotiation between the parties” (para 72), and that “the defendant has failed to raise a credible challenge to the validity of the suit patents. Thus, once the infringement has been established by the plaintiff, it is entitled to grant of injunction by application of section 48 of the Patents Act, 1970” (para 99). The defendant was “injuncted from manufacturing, importing, selling, offering for sale its devices”, the order to “become operative w.e.f. 21st June, 2016” subject to a stay on a deposit of “Rs.50 crores”. (paras 114–115)
An unwilling licensee. “it appears prima facie that the defendant is an unwilling licensee, in view of the lack of bonafide displayed in its conduct during the negotiation between the parties”, the defendant not having “shown its willingness as per its contract to obtain licence with respect to the plaintiff’s standard essential patents relating to inter alia 2G and 3G technology.” (para 72)
Others pay, the defendant does not. “All other similarly placed parties viz., Micromax, Gionee, Xiaomi, iBall, etc., are all paying royalties to Plaintiff or depositing amounts in Court and Defendant is getting an unfair advantage in the market, firstly, by conducting its business without royalty payment and secondly by delaying the FRAND” (“fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory”) “determination before this Court.” (para 71)
No credible challenge; section 48. “the defendant has failed to raise a credible challenge to the validity of the suit patents. Thus, once the infringement has been established by the plaintiff, it is entitled to grant of injunction by application of section 48 of the Patents Act, 1970 especially in view of the fact that the defendant has admitted the validity and essentiality of the suit patents.” (para 99)
The monopoly is the inventor’s reward. The Division Bench in Telemecanique & Controls v Schneider Electric (2001) had held that “once a violation is established in case of a registered patent, subject of course, to the patent being used, it will not be permissible to contend that the said patentee is not entitled to an injunction. A monopoly of the patent is the reward of the inventor.” (para 100)
Injunction for a standard-essential patent. “once patent prima facie held to be infringed and no credible defence is established, injunction must follow even in cases of standard essential, if any party is reluctant or unwilling and deliberately and intentionally avoiding to enter into license agreement on flimsy grounds, the injunction order is to be passed.” (para 109)
Balance of convenience. “the plaintiff has been able to make out a strong prima facie case in its favour and against the defendant. Balance of convenience also lies in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. In case the interim order is not passed or the defendant is not ready to enter into FRAND agreement with the plaintiff, the other licensee would also take the same stand which is being taken by the defendant.” (para 111)
The defendant’s own suit as admission. “the defendant has filed the suit in Noida Court before the negotiations are terminated. As mentioned earlier, the said suit filed by the defendant would disclose that the defendant was inclined to execute the FRAND agreement on reasonable terms. The said admission of the defendant itself would show that the defendant was aware that the plaintiff has prima-facie rights in the patents.” (para 113)
Procedure. The cross-application dismissed. “The application filed by the defendant being I.A. No.16011/2015, which is false and frivolous, is dismissed”, “with cost of Rs.50,000/- which shall be deposited by the defendant with the Prime Minister’s National Relief Fund, within two weeks from today.” (para 114)
Procedure. The injunction and the stay condition. The defendant was “injuncted from manufacturing, importing, selling, offering for sale its devices including phones, tablets, dongles, etc. which infringe the plaintiff’s patented technology”, “All Custom Authorities in India are directed not to release the impugned mobile phones”; but “if the defendant, without prejudice, will deposit a sum of Rs.50 crores with the Registrar General of this Court by way of FDR as security amount on or before 20th June, 2016, the operation of interim order shall remain stayed till the final disposal of the main suit.” (paras 114–115)
No later judicial treatment and no further appeal traced as of 2 November 2026.
High Court of Delhi
Case page · Page updated 10 November 2026
www.aop.onl/ericsson-lava-2016