Bayer Corporation v Union of India (2014)
High Court of Bombay·15 July 2014
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
What is the procedure on an application for a compulsory licence under section 84?
Under section 87 the Controller proceeds on a compulsory licence application only where a prima facie case has been made out, and shall publish the application in the Official Journal.
Doctrine last updated on 14 November 2026
Procedure on a Compulsory Licence Application, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/compulsory-licence-procedure
1The Patents Act lays down detailed procedure for applications preferred under ss 84 and 85.
2In an application made under s 84 or s 85 of the Patents Act, if the Controller is satisfied that the time which has elapsed since the grant of patent has not been sufficient to work the invention on a commercial scale or to enable the invention to be worked to the fullest extent, the Controller may by order adjourn further hearing of the application for a period aggregating to not more than 12 months. This provision ensures that sufficient time is given to work an invention. The elapse of time is to be computed from the date of ‘grant of the patent’ and not from the date of ‘sealing of patent’, as mentioned in s 86(1). (Though the phrase ‘sealing of patent’ has been replaced with the phrase ‘grant of patent’, certain sections, namely ss 84(6)(i), 86(1), 91(1) and 92(1) still retain the old phrase ‘sealing of patent’, probably due to oversight. However, the substitution is carried out at the outset in s 84(1).)
3If the inability to work the patented invention is due to a restriction imposed by a Central or state Act, rule or regulation or order of Government, then the period of adjournment shall be computed from the date on which such restriction expires. An adjournment shall not be ordered if the Controller is satisfied that the patentee has not taken adequate steps to start working the invention in India on a commercial scale. When an application is made to the Controller and the Controller is satisfied that a prima facie case for making a grant has been made out, he shall direct the applicant to serve copies of the application upon the patentee and other interested persons. The Controller shall publish the application in the Official Journal. If necessary, the Controller may require the applicant to file a draft licence along with the application.
4In Bayer v Union of India (2014) the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that “Section 86 of the Act which provides for adjourning application for compulsory licence has to essentially satisfy two conditions”: that “The time which has lapsed since the patent was granted and when an application for compulsory licence was made was insufficient to enable the patent holder to work the patented drug in India on a commercial scale; and” that “Patent holder should have taken steps towards working the patented drug in India on a commercial scale with promptitude.” It found that “The petitioner has led no evidence before the authorities to indicate what steps they have taken and with what promptitude the same have been taken for the purposes of working the patent in India after 2008.” (para 16)
5The patentee or any interested persons intending to oppose the application, may, within the time stipulated, give notice of opposition to the Controller containing the statement setting out the grounds of opposition. An exclusive licensee may also oppose an application. (See Colbourne Engineering Co Ltd’s Application (1955) 72 RPC 169.) Upon receipt of the notice, the Controller shall notify the applicant and shall give the applicant and the opponent an opportunity to be heard. (Patents Act 1970, s 87(4).)
6Notice of opposition shall be given in Form 14 and shall be sent to the Controller within two months from the date of publication of the application in the Official Journal. Where the opponent is the patentee, the notice may include the terms and conditions of the licence which the patentee is prepared to grant. The notice shall be accompanied by evidence supporting the opposition. The opponent shall serve a copy on the applicant and shall notify the Controller of such service. The Controller shall fix a date for the hearing of the opposition, which will be conducted like a post-grant opposition hearing. (Patents Rules 2003, r 62.)
7An application may be made by the patentee or any interested person, under s 94, to the Controller for the termination of a compulsory licence granted under s 84 on the ground that the circumstances under which the licence was granted no longer exist and they are unlikely to recur. (Patents Act 1970, s 94.) The holder of the compulsory licence shall have a right to object to such termination. In considering an application for termination, the Controller shall have regard to the fact that the interest of the person who had previously been granted a compulsory licence is not prejudiced. The above section reflects the principle contained in art 31(g) of the TRIPS Agreement.
8An application for termination of compulsory licence granted under s 84 shall be made by the patentee or any other person as given in Form 21. The application shall be supported by the necessary evidence. (Patents Rules 2003, r 102(1).) The applicant shall serve a copy of the application and evidence, on the holder of the compulsory licence and shall inform the Controller of the service. Within one month from the receipt of the application and evidence, the holder of compulsory licence may file his objection along with evidence to the Controller and serve a copy on the applicant. (Ibid, r 102(3).) Once the pleadings are complete from either side, the Controller may fix a date and time for hearing the case after giving notice to the parties. The procedure of such hearing shall be the same as that of post-grant opposition. (Patents Rules 2003, r 62.) If the Controller decides to terminate the compulsory licence, he shall issue an order giving the terms and conditions of such termination and shall serve copies on the parties.
Is Chapter XVI a complete code on abuse of patent rights?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/compulsory-licence-procedure