Doctrine page

Compulsory Licences as Transfers

Can the holder of a compulsory licence assign it or grant sub-licences?

Under section 84(4) a compulsory licence should be non-exclusive and of a non-assignable nature, and the general rule is that the licensee has no power to grant sub-licences.

Doctrine last updated on 14 November 2026

Cite this page

Compulsory Licences as Transfers, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/compulsory-licence-as-transfer

1As in the case of any right in moveable property, patents too can be the subject matter of transfers and assignments. (Patents Act 1970, s 70.) The Patents Act provides for certain exclusive rights to the patentee which are enforceable within the territory of India. (Ibid, s 48.) The grant of a patent for a product confers an exclusive right on the patentee to prevent third parties from making, using, offering for sale, selling or importing that product. With regard to process patents, the exclusivity is limited to preventing others from the act of using that process, and from the act of using, offering for sale, selling or importing the product obtained directly by the process. A patentee can transfer or assign any of these rights to any person. The Patents Act empowers any person registered as a grantee or proprietor of a patent to assign, grant licences under, or otherwise deal with the patent for consideration. (Ibid, s 70.) The power to transfer a right in a patent is broad in its scope as it includes the right to transfer a patent in whole or in part and the right to assign or licence a patent, exclusively or generally.

2The Patents Act provides for a mechanism by which every transfer and assignment is recorded in the register of patents so that persons dealing with patents will have knowledge of the title, property, interest or right in or under a patent that will prevail in case of conflicting claims. The purpose of entry in the register is to inform the public about the owner of the monopoly. (See LG Electronics Inc v NCR Financial Solutions Group Ltd [2003] FSR 24, para 18.) It provides a means for a person to know about an interest in the patent through inspection of the register.

3Section 67 of the Patents Act provides for ’notifications of assignment and of transmissions of patents, of licences under patents’ to be entered into the register of patents. Section 68 requires an assignment of a share or an interest in a patent to be in writing and an agreement between the parties concerned to be in the form of a document embodying all the terms and conditions governing the rights and obligations and the same to be duly executed. Section 69 of the Patents Act and rr 90 to 92 of the Patents Rules deal with the procedure for registration of assignments, transmissions or operation of law. Section 70 deals with the power of a registered grantee or a proprietor to deal with a patent. Section 140 provides for the avoidance of certain restrictive conditions in contracts relating to patents. Section 141 deals with determination of certain contracts dealing with patents.

4The provisions of the Patents Act are comparable to the provision of the UK Patents Act 1949. Section 73(1) of the UK Patents Act 1949 dealt with entry of notification of assignments and transmission in registers. Section 74 dealt with the procedure for registration of assignments and transmissions. Section 74(4) detailed the powers of a patentee to deal with the patent. Section 57 dealt with the avoidance of certain restrictive conditions in contracts relating to patents. Section 58 provided for the determination of certain contracts dealing with patents. The provisions of the UK Patents Act 1949 have been replaced by the UK Patents Act 1977. Sections 30 to 38 of the UK Patents Act 1977 deal with property in patents and applications, and registration. Sections 44 and 45 of the UK Patents Act 1977 which dealt with ‘Avoidance of certain restrictive conditions’ and ‘Determination of parts of certain contract’ were repealed by the UK Competition Act 1998.

5The law applicable to the ownership and devolution of movable property generally shall apply to patents. (Patents Act 1970, ss 50(5) and 70.) The person registered as the grantee or proprietor has the power to assign, grant licences under or deal in any manner with, the patent. The patent may be transferred by assignment, transmission or operation of law. (Ibid, s 69.) Upon the grant of a patent, the Controller shall enter in the register of patents the details of the grantee as the patentee. Such details include, the name, address (including address for service) and nationality of the patentee, the title of the invention (including the categories to which the invention relates), the date of the patent and the date of grant. (Patents Rules 2003, r 88.)

6The register of patents shall be prima facie evidence of any matters required or authorised by or under the Patents Act. (Patents Act 1970, s 72(2).) Similarly, a certificate purporting to be signed by the Controller as to any entry, matter or thing which he is authorised by the Patents Act or the Patents Rules to make or do, shall be prima facie evidence of the entry having been made and of the contents and of the matter or thing, done or omitted. (Ibid, s 147(2).) In fact, the Patents Act expressly states that the examination and investigation with regard to an application done by the Patent Office shall not warrant the validity of any patent. (Ibid, s 13(4).)

7The applicant shall not be entitled to institute any proceedings for infringement until the patent is granted. (Ibid, s 11A(7).) The right to institute a suit in respect of any infringement of the patent is vested with the patentee or its exclusive licensee. (Ibid, s 109(1).) The Patents Act provides that a person ‘registered as grantee or proprietor of a patent’ shall have power to assign, grant licences under, or otherwise deal with the patent, subject to any equities in respect of the patent. (Ibid, s 70.) Thus, the rights of a patent vest in the person registered as the grantee or proprietor. (This is similar to the position in the United Kingdom under s 74(4) of the UK Patents Act 1949. However, the position in the United Kingdom has changed with the coming into force of s 61 of the UK Patents Act 1977.) The person registered as the grantee or proprietor can refer either to the original grantee or a person who subsequently obtains title to the patent through an assignment under the Patents Act.

8In determining questions of devolution of the right in a patent it is important to first determine ’the person for the time being entered on the register as the grantee or the proprietor of the patent.’ (See definition of ‘patentee’ in the Patents Act 1970, s 2(1)(p).) The Patents Act refers to the patentee as the person whose name is for the time being entered into the register as the grantee or the proprietor. The Patents Act uses the terms ‘grantee’ and ‘proprietor’ alternatively to refer to the patentee. (See the Patents Act 1970, s 11A(7), which is the only provision where the term ‘patent-holder’ is used.) The term ‘proprietor’ is not defined under the Patents Act. Though the patentee is not referred to as the owner under the Patents Act, there is reference to co-owners. (Ibid, s 50.) The patentee is the owner of the patent who is capable of taking decisions with regard to assignment, mortgage and licence of patents. It is the patentee who can file a suit for infringement. (Ibid, s 109 also provides for the holder of an exclusive licence to institute an infringement suit.)

9The transfer of a patent by transmission or by operation of law refers to the instances of transfer occasioned by death of the patentee, insolvency of the patentee, dissolution of a company and acquisition by the Central Government. The rights of a patentee include the right to grant assignments, licences and mortgages.""

10The grant of the licence should be non-exclusive so as to encourage trade and competition.

11The compulsory licence should be of a non-assignable nature. In case a person is desirous of procuring a compulsory licence which has already been granted, a separate application has to be made to the Controller. The general rule is that the licensee has no power to grant sub-licences. (See Allen & Hanburys Ltd’s (Salbutamol) Patent (1987) RPC 327, p 380 (CA).) But the compulsory licence can provide for sub-licensing in exceptional cases. (See Therma-Tru Corp’s Patent (1997) RPC 777, pp 795-96 where it was held that there was no exceptional case established for the grant of a sub-licence. See also Hilti AG’s Patent [1987] FSR 594, (1988) RPC 51, p 68.) A licence should not be granted if it would be worked by a sub-licensee and not by the applicant. (See Therma-Tru Corpn’s Patent (1997) RPC 777.)

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

See also

Doctrine page

Terms of a Compulsory Licence

What terms and royalty does the Controller settle in a compulsory licence?

Doctrine page

Assignment

What does it take to assign a patent in India?

Doctrine page

Transfer of Patent Rights

What is the difference between assigning a patent and transferring only an interest in it?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/compulsory-licence-as-transfer