Doctrine page

Ambiguity and the Patentee's Risk

Is a patent invalid for ambiguous claims even where the obscurity is careless rather than deliberate?

Under section 64(1)(i) a patent whose language is avoidably obscure or ambiguous is invalid, whether the defect be due to design, or to carelessness or to want of skill.

Doctrine last updated on 17 November 2026

Cite this page

Ambiguity and the Patentee's Risk, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/ambiguous-claims

1The purposive method of construction will not permit the introduction of any additional requirement over and above the ones stipulated by law. However, it is permissible for the court to introduce the requirements stated in s 10 of the Patents Act, the ingredients of which any complete specification must necessarily comply with. For instance, the court may introduce, by way of construction, the requirement that the claim must be fairly based on the matter disclosed in the specification. (Patents Act 1970, s 10(5).) The UK Patents Act 1949 provided for such a requirement too. However, in Auchincloss v Agricultural & Veterinary Supplies Ltd, a case decided by the Court of Appeal in the context of the UK Patents Act 1977, it was held that the introduction of a requirement that the claim must be fairly based on the patent specification will not be permissible as the same was no longer a requirement under the UK Patents Act 1977. ((1999) RPC 397, p 402 (CA).)

2The requirement of disclosure to third parties is a vital part of a complete specification. The Patents Act requires every specification to fully and particularly describe the invention and its operation or use and the method by which it is to be performed. (Patents Act 1970, s 10(4)(a).) The purposive construction will not allow the court to resolve a doubt in favour of the patentee or in favour of a strict or literal construction. (Assidoman Multipak Ltd v Mead Corpn (1995) RPC 321, p 332.) Such an approach would result in rewarding opaque drafting. (BASF AG v SmithKline Beecham Plc (2003) RPC 49, para 104 (CA).) A specification must be construed impartially, in a neutral manner without ’narrowing or widening the boundaries of the monopoly fixed by the plain words of a claim’. (See Lallubhai Chakubhai Jariwala v Chimanlal Chunilal & Co AIR 1936 Bom 99, p 105.) It follows that courts shall be reluctant to resolve difficulties in construction either in favour of the patentee or against the patentee. (Electric and Musical Industries Ltd v Lissen Ltd [1938] 4 All ER 221, (1939) 56 RPC 23 (HL) per Lord Russell of Killowen.) (BASF AG v SmithKline Beecham Plc (2003) RPC 49, para 103 (CA).) (See Scanvaegt v Pelcombe [1998] FSR 786, p 796.)

3Lack of sufficiency is a ground for revocation of a patent under the Patents Act. (Patents Act 1970, s 64(1)(h).) Similarly, if the scope of any claim of the complete specification is not sufficiently or clearly defined, it could also be a ground for revocation. (Ibid, s 64(1)(i).) But the mere fact that a word, phrase or other provision in a patent claim is not wholly clear will not automatically lead to the conclusion that the claim is objectionable, as this would set an unrealistic standard for drafting in any field. A claim needs to be as clear as the subject matter reasonably permits. (LG Philips LCD Co Ltd v Tatung (UK) Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 1774, para 20.)

4Sufficient care should be taken in drafting patents as cautioned by Lord Loreburn in Natural Colour Kinematograph Ltd v Bioschemes Ltd: ((1915) 32 RPC 256, p 266.)

I think this patent is bad for ambiguity in the specification. There seems to be some danger of the well-known rule of law against ambiguity being in practice invaded. Some of those who draft specifications and claims are apt to treat this industry as a trial of skill, in which the object is to make the claim very wide upon one interpretation of it, in order to prevent as many people as possible from competing with the patentee’s business, and then to rely upon carefully prepared sentences in the specification which, it is hoped, will be just enough to limit the claim within safe dimensions if this is attacked in court. This leads to litigation as to the construction of specifications, which could generally be avoided if at the outset a sincere attempt were made to state exactly what was meant in plain language. The fear of a costly law suit is apt to deter any but wealthy competitors from contesting a patent. This is all wrong. It is an abuse which a court can prevent, whether a charge of ambiguity is or is not raised on the pleadings because it affects the public by practically enlarging the monopoly, and does so by a kind of pressure which is very objectionable. It is the duty of a patentee to state clearly and distinctly, either in direct words or by clear and distinct reference, the nature and limits of what he claims. If he uses language which, when fairly read, is avoidably obscure or ambiguous, the patent is invalid, whether the defect be due to design, or to carelessness or to want of skill. When the invention is difficult to explain, due allowance will, of course, be made for any resulting difficulty in the language.

But nothing can excuse the use of ambiguous language when simple language can easily be employed, and the only safe way is for the patentee to do his best to be clear and intelligible. It is necessary to emphasize this warning. To my mind, this is a very plain case of offence against the rule to which I have referred. I cannot see what purpose there could have been for using the roundabout language here employed, which has provoked so much argumentative subtlety and taken up so much time, unless the object was to hold in reverse a variety of constructions for use if the patent should be called into question, and in the meantime to frighten off those who might be disposed to challenge the patent.

5In Press Metal v Noshir Sorabji Pochkhanawalla (1982), allowing the opponents’ appeal and refusing the patent on the ground of insufficiency under section 25(1)(g), the Bombay High Court held that “It is the duty of a patents to state clearly and distinctly the nature and limits of what he claims. if the language used by the patentee is obscure and ambiguous, no patent can be granted and it is immaterial whether the obscurity in the language is due to design or carelessness or want of skill. It is undoubtedly true that the language used in describing an invention would depend upon the class of persons versed in the art and who intend to act upon the specification. In the present case as already stated above, the invention is described in an obscure and ambiguous language, and on the ground also the patent is liable to be refused.” (para 41) Of the claim before it the Court said that “claim No. 1 ambiguous, as it appear to me, to be no more than a workshop modification” (para 36), and it reproduced the Controller’s own observation that “the principal claim itself does not clearly distinguish the characterising feature of the invention” (para 8).

6A claim in a specification will not be ambiguous merely because some part of it is capable of more than one construction or is difficult to construe. (Henriksen v Tallon Ltd (1965) RPC 434, p 443, [1965] FSR 215 (HL).) In such cases, the court should prefer the sensible construction and would read the claim in such a manner so as to avoid an absurd result. (Ibid.) As the patentee is free to use the language he likes to define his invention, ’the court has to guard against being impressed by the form and language of the claims rather than the substance of the patentee’s alleged technical contribution’. (Raychem Corpn’s Patents (1998) RPC 31, p 37.) Where the claims are prolix and opaque, the court should break free of the language and concern itself with what the claims really mean. (Ibid.) An ambiguous claim can result in the patentee being unable to establish infringement. (See Scanvaegt International a/s v Pelcombe Ltd [1998] FSR 786, p 797 (CA). See also Milliken Denmark a/s v Walk Off Mats Ltd [1996] FSR 292, p 301.) The courts may also impose costs for poor and ambiguous drafting. (See Lubrizol Corpn v Esso Petroleum Co Ltd (1998) RPC 727, p 788.)

7Ambiguous claims are drafted so that the patentee may claim the widest possible scope for the invention. The courts have cautioned not to interpret the claims so as to give a patentee the widest possible scope. Referring to an earlier decision, Lord Hoffmann said in Kirin-Amgen: (Kirin-Amgen Inc v Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd (2005) RPC 9, para 33.)

The only point on which I would question the otherwise admirable summary of the law on infringement in the judgment of Jacob LJ in Rockwater Ltd v Technip France SA (unreported) [2004] EWCA Civ 381, at [41], is when he says in sub-para (e) that to be ‘fair to the patentee’ one must use ’the widest purpose consistent with his teaching’. This, as it seems to me, is to confuse the purpose of the utterance with what it would be understood to mean. The purpose of a patent specification, as I have said, is no more nor less than to communicate the idea of an invention. An appreciation of that purpose is part of the material which one uses to ascertain the meaning. But purpose and meaning are different. If, when speaking of the widest purpose, Jacob LJ meant the widest meaning, I would respectfully disagree. There is no presumption about the width of the claims. A patent may, for one reason or another, claim less than it teaches or enables.

Provisions and topics

Provisions
Topics

Cases on this page

Case page

Lallubhai Chakubhai Jariwala v Chimanlal Chunilal & Co (1935)

High Court of Bombay·3 April 1935

See also

Doctrine page

Sufficiency of Disclosure

What must a complete specification disclose to be sufficient in India?

Doctrine page

Insufficiency as a Ground of Revocation

When can a patent be revoked for insufficient disclosure in India?

Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali

www.aop.onl/ambiguous-claims