Allergan Inc v Controller of Patents (2023)
High Court of Delhi·20 January 2023
Latest update: . Case: Hanmi Pharm Co Ltd v Controller General of Patents and Designs. Doctrine: Amendment Before the Controller.
Doctrine last updated on 17 November 2026
Matter Not in Substance Disclosed, Ali on Patents, www.aop.onl/added-matter
1Section 59(1) of the Patents Act provides that no amendment shall be allowed the effect of which would be that the specification amended would claim or describe matter not in substance disclosed or shown in the unamended specification. The Patents Act prohibits such amendments as the effect of which would be to claim a new matter undisclosed in the complete specification before the amendment. Section 59(1) of the Patents Act must be construed in a broad common sense manner giving liberal interpretation to cover any fair amendment which has already been in substance disclosed. (See Ethyl Corpn’s Patent [1970] FSR 1, pp 4-5, 8 (1972) RPC 169 (CA), a case pertaining to the equivalent provision, s 31(1) of the UK Patents Act 1949. See also Esso Research and Engineering Co Ltd’s Application (1960) RPC 35 (CA); AMP Inc v Hellerman Ltd (1962) RPC 55, [1962] 1 WLR 241 (HL).) Where the specification gave examples of how to produce the chemical substance (an anti-knock composition comprising of tetramethyl lead and a hydrocarbon) showing several different proportions of hydrocarbon to tetramethyl lead in the end product (20 percent, 45 percent, 80 percent), an amendment to specify the range of percentage (from 20 to 80 percent) would be allowed. Such amendment was in substance disclosed in the unamended specification as the original specification contained examples of compositions within the said range. (Ibid, pp 3-5.)
2In Andreas Gutzeit v Controller General of Patents Designs and Trademark (2025), the Calcutta High Court set out the test of added matter in the words of Jacob J in Richardson-Vick Inc’s Patent (1995) RPC 568, p 576, “I think the test of added matter is whether a skilled man would, upon looking at the amended specification, learn anything about the invention which he could not learn from the unamended specification.” It then gave the reason, with its English source named, “The reason behind this rule was identified and examined in Vector Corp vs. Glatt Air Techniques Ltd. (2007) EWCA Civ 805. A third party must be able to look at an application and be able to draw a conclusion with respect to the subject matter that is available for supporting a claimed monopoly. A subject matter if added subsequently, the patentee could obtain a different monopoly to that which the application originally justified.” The order under appeal “simply fails to deal with this aspect of the matter.” (para 20) Of the finding itself the Court held that “In passing the impugned order, the Assistant Controller though aware of the fact that the original claim mentioned contrast dye failed to discuss whether the same fell within the scope of the original specification or not”, and that “The impugned order does not decide whether the invention is comprehended within the matter disclosed or not.” (para 19)
3In determining whether the specification as amended would claim or describe matter not in substance disclosed or shown in the specification before the amendment, the Controller shall consider the following:
(a) To ascertain through the eyes of the skilled addressee what is disclosed, both explicitly and impliedly in the application; (b) To do the same in respect of the application as sought to be amended; (c) To compare the two disclosures and decide whether the amended specification would ‘claim or describe matter not in substance disclosed or shown in the specification before the amendment’ and whether the amended specification would ’not fall wholly within the scope of a claim of the specification before amendment’. (See Bonzel v Intervention Ltd (No 3) (1991) RPC 553, p 574; Flexible Directional Indicators Ltd’s Application (1994) RPC 207, p 226. The above tests were developed in the context of the UK Patents Act 1977. The third step, as decided in the above cases in United Kingdom, requires that the amended specification shall not ‘disclose additional matter, that is, matter extending beyond that disclosed in the earlier application, as filed, or the application for the patent, as filed.’ Under s 59 of the Patents Act 1970, the test is that the amended specification shall not ‘claim or describe matter not in substance disclosed or shown in the specification before the amendment.’ Hence the same has been substituted for the third step.)
4In Allergan v Controller of Patents (2023) the Delhi High Court found that “Each claim stands fully disclosed in the complete specifications accompanying the unamended claims.” (para 22)
5In EMD Millipore v Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (2025) the Delhi High Court held that “This Court is conscious of the fact that this specific limiting feature was not present in the originally filed independent claims. However, the said embodiment is disclosed in the Complete Specification” and that it was disclosed “as a preferred embodiment. This amendment, therefore, does not introduce any new matter but merely incorporates a preferred embodiment into the Claim. The inclusion of this limitation narrows the scope of the claim and enhances its precision, and is accordingly, permissible under Section 59 of the Act.” (para 79) It concluded that “the amended claim falls within the scope of what was originally disclosed and claimed, and the requirements of Section 59 of the Act stand duly satisfied.” (para 81)
High Court of Delhi·9 October 2025
High Court of Calcutta·15 May 2025
What amendments to a patent application or specification are permitted under section 59?
Doctrine page · Written by Prof. Feroz Ali
www.aop.onl/added-matter